News Update

Mahashtra election: Cash of Rs 86 lakh recovered from car in MumbaiCBDT clarifies on CoD for returns claiming deduction u/s 80P for AY 2023-24 + specifies Forms for rollback of APA & applications u/s 35CCCCBIC revises tariff value of edible oils, gold and silverUK Budget to mop up 40 bn pound from tax hikes for wealthy BritonsVietnamese, Philippine exports to America surge for second consecutive quarter as global supply chain shiftsUN calls for probe of killings in Bangladesh protestsChina’s factory output & services perk up in Oct monthChina initiates probe against AstraZenca chief in ChinaN Korean troops to return in body bags if they enter Ukraine: USUS economy grows by 2.8% in Q3National Internet Exchange of India unveils new office at World Trade Centre, New DelhiCus - CBIC appoints adjudicators for 60 casesIndian Railways signs MoU with Switzerland's DETEC to enhance Technological CollaborationGST - Working of Rule 96(10) has resulted in hostile discrimination amongst exporters who opt to apply for a refund u/s 16(3)(a) of IGST Act r/w Rule 89 of the CGST Rules and those who opt to apply for a refund in the manner contemplated by s.16(3)(b) - Rule 96(10) is manifestly arbitrary, hence ultra vires: HC51 killed in devastating flooding in SpainGST - Circular 231 prevails over the impugned order - ITC benefit available on demo vehicles: HCIndia-China border disengagement enters into last stretchGST - Secondment of employees - IGST demand - SCNs are rendered impotent in view of Board Circular 210/4/2024 - When value of services is accepted as Nil, no further tax implication would arise: HCUN says West Asia is at ‘most dangerous juncture’ amid rising Israel-Iran mercuryGST - It is not for this Court to be boggled by or question the wisdom of the CBIC as the Circular in any case binds the respondents: HCGST - Establishing that Appeal memo was signed by authorised signatory - Bench does not approve of the appellate authorities adopting shortcuts and dismissing the appeals: HCGST - Plea of the petitioner having an alternative remedy cannot be accepted as violation of principles of natural justice is an exception to the said plea: HCCX - Cash refund is not permissible where an assessee is unable to utilize credit on Inputs upon closure of unit - CESTAT orders are not error-prone: HCWheeling and Dealing: The Taxing Tale of Demo VehiclesCus - CBIC releases revised list of high-end refurbished medical equipmentCX - Govt notifies concessional excise duty for operators under UDANMudra Yojana: Loan Limit raised to Rs 20 Lakh from Rs 10 LakhGST & Customs relief to reduce MRP of 3 Anti-cancer Drugs: GovtI-T - Purchase of rights shares which does not contribute to income of assessee, can't be taxed: HCESIC network up from 393 Districts to 674 Districts now: Union Minister
 
GST on TDR

AUGUST 04, 2023

By Dr Sanjay Kalra, LLM., Ph.D.(GST Law), Advocate, KPS Legal

LEVY of GST on TDR has always been a debatable topic among stakeholders, since inception of the GST Act, 2017. For understanding the subject matter, first we should understand the difference between the two terms 'Transferable Development Rights' and 'Transfer of Development Rights'. These two terms should not be used loosely while determining the taxability of TDR under GST Act, 2017.

Transferable Development Rights (TDR) :

'Transferable Development Rights'  (TDR) means certificates issued in respect of category of land acquired for public purposes either by the Central or State Government in consideration of surrender of land by the owner without monetary compensation, which are transferable in part or whole [Para 2.1.46 of Consolidated FDI Policy Circular dated 28-8-2017]. Similarly, 'TDR' is also defined in  Section 6(2) of FEMA. Thus, TDR is a right given by authority to construct/develop land upto a certain permissible Floor Space Index (FSI) within permissible limits of Development Control Regulations. TDR is an award which entitles the owner of the land in the form of a Development Rights Certificate (DRC) which he may use for himself or transfer it to any other person.

Transfer of 'Development Rights' (DR):

Transfer of 'Development Rights' means supply of 'Development Rights', by Owner of the land to a Developer / Builder / Construction Company, for constructing a complex, building or civil structure. Here, the said owner avails the 'Construction Service' from such Developer / Builder against a consideration, wholly or partly, in form of the said constructed complex, building or civil structure by getting possession thereof from such Developer / Builder.

TDR is different from Transfer of 'Development Rights'   - In TDR, Government (local authority) gives an instrument to land owner (for surrender of his right) to either use it or sell it. In Transfer of Development Rights, the owner of land allows promoter to develop the land on behalf of the landowner against a consideration.

Taxability of 'TDR' in a GST Regime

TDR would be taxable if it amounts to supply of "service" or supply of "Goods" under the GST Act, 2017. To decide the issue, let us refer to the definition of goods and services as provided in the Constitution of India as well as under the CGST Act, 2017- Article 366(1 2) and 366 (26A) of the Constitution of India define "goods' and 'services'.

Whether TDR is 'Goods'

As per Article 366(12) of the Constitution of India, "goods" includes all materials, commodities. Section 2(52) of the CGST Act, 2017 defines "goods" means every kind of movable property other than money and securities but includes actionable claim, growing crops, grass and things attached to or forming part of the land which are agreed to be severed before supply or under a contract of supply. Let us understand definitions of the following relevant terms:

1. 'Movable Property' : The Tax Enactments do not define 'Movable Property'. Even the General Clauses Act says that that movable property means property of every kind, except immovable property.

2. 'Immovable Property' : The term ‘immovable property’ has not been defined under GST law. The General Clauses Act, 1897 defines "immovable property" as to include land, benefits to arise out of land, and things attached to the earth, or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth. Section 2(6) of the Registration Act, 1908 defines “immovable property” to include land, buildings, hereditary allowances, rights to ways, lights, ferries, fisheries or any other benefit to arise out of land, and things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything which is attached to the earth, but not standing timber, growing crops nor grass.

3. 'Land' : Section 3(4) of the Bombay Land Revenue Code, 1879 defines "Land" as under:

"Land" includes benefits to arise out of land, and things attached to the earth, or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth a ri d also shares in or charges on the revenue or rent of village or other defined portions of territory.

4. 'Benefits to arise out of land' :The Apex court also held that 'land' includes rights in or over land and benefits to arise out of land [Safiya Bee vs Mohd. Vajahath Hussain - (2011) 2 SCC 94; Pradeep Oil Corporation vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi - (2011) 5 SCC 270]. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in various judgements held that the benefits arising out of land is an interest in immovable property [Anand Behera v. State of Orissa (1955) 2 SCR919; Shantabai V. State of Bombay AIR 1958 SC532; Bibi Sayeeda v. State of Bihar (1996) 9 SCC 516].

TDR being an immovable property is not covered under 'Goods' : From the above definitions and the law clarified by various Courts, it comes out that TDR is the benefit arising out of land and so the same is an immovable property. This view is further strengthened by the fact that a purchase of TDR is registered with the sub-registrar as applicable to an immovable property. Hence, the TDR being an immovable property is not covered under the definition of goods.

Whether TDR is neither 'Goods' nor 'Services' : Schedule III to the CGST Act, 2017 contains a negative list, enlisting activities which shall neither be treated as supply of goods nor supply of services. Paragraph 5 of Schedule III covers 'sale of land and, subject to clause (b) of paragraph 5 of Schedule II, sale of building'. In this context, please note that the Apex Court held that Land Development Right is a Right to carry out development or to develop the land or building or both [Girnar Traders vs State of Maharashtra - (2011) 3 SCC 1)]. Also in another case, the Apex Court held that Land Development Right is thus a benefit out of land included within the word 'land' [S.N. Chandrasekhar vs State of Karnataka - (2006) 3SCC 208; Dena Bank vs B.B.P.Parekh & Co. - (2000) 5 SCC694].

From the above, it is crystal clear that TDR is a benefit arising out of land and transfer of TDR gives the recipient an irrevocable and permanent development right on such land. TDR may be covered under 'sale of land' in Entry No. 5 of schedule III of the CGST Act. Therefore, TDR is neither 'supply of goods' nor 'supply of services'.

Taxability of 'Transfer of 'Development Rights' (DR):

As explained above, the owner of a land avails the 'Construction Service' from a Developer / Builder by transferring 'Development Rights' to such Developer / Builder against a consideration, wholly or partly, in form of the said constructed complex, building or civil structure by getting possession thereof from such Developer / Builder. Such transfer of Development Rights (DR) is a supply of service taxable under entry at SI. No. 16 (iii) ( Heading 9972)under Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 bearing description "Real estate services other than (i) and (ii) above", and accordingly, would attract GST at the rate of 1 8% (9% CGST + 9% SGST). Notification No.4/2018-CentralTax(Rate) dated 25.01.2018 has notified that a registered person who supplies development rights to a developer shall be a Taxable Person. The Notification No. 5/2019 -C.T. (Rate). dated 29.03.2019 has been issued amending Notification No. 13/2017 -C.T. (Rate), dated 28.06.2017 whereby service by way of transfer of development rights/Additional FSI by any person to the promoter were made taxable under reverse charge.

Conclusion :

'Transferable Development Rights' certificates (TDR) issued by the Government for the land acquired is an immovable property. The sale of TDR being covered by Schedule III is not taxable under CGST Act, 2017. However, transfer of 'Development Rights' being a 'Construction Service' under Heading 9972 is taxable as a supply of service under the GST Act, 2017.

[The views expressed are strictly personal.]

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and Taxindiaonline.com doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Taxindiaonline.com Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)

 RECENT DISCUSSION(S) POST YOUR COMMENTS
   
 
Sub: tdr

sir no where in the statute the word development rights or transferable development rights words or phrases are used sir.
these are generated by common people or consultants and then picked up by the council and used in notifications and circulars, which has become a bureaucratic practice now a days.

when development on land is development only then its rights are also land na sir. then schedule 3 item only.
builder gets the permission only to enter and construct the project , nothing can be transferred for that by the land owner neither the land nor the rights thereon . referring to certain hsn code can not bring the taxability. article is nice and started as well too, but sir at end it has spoken the language of the revenue.

decisions in the ananda behre, chheda housing, sadoday builders etc are very relevant till today hold good.

no taxability as there is no supply it self

Posted by Navin Khandelwal
 
Sub: tdr

the word used is the transfer
means the transfer by way of a conveyance deed or any similar document and certainly not the possession by way of an allotment letter.
development rights never transferred by way of joint development agreement. if at all transferred for a consideration of some construction or development service carrying direct nexus there to , by the developer then only supply

Posted by Navin Khandelwal
 

TIOL Tube Latest

Conferment of TIOL Awards 2024. The event was held on October 1, 2024 at Taj Palace, New Delhi



Technical Session I - Ease of Doing Business: GST on Digital Economy