News Update

A series of fires in Delhi - 16 cars gutted in East Delhi + 5 shops damaged in Chandni ChowkIndia discusses mobility of healthcare professionals to UK with Lord MarkhamClimate Finance: Rich countries contributed about USD 116 bn in 2022: OECDNSDC, ILO forge strategic partnership to enhance Skill DevelopmentSC tosses out Kejriwal’s plea to extend interim bailHome Voting for eligible voters extended pan-India for first time in Elections 2024PM skewers Mamata for changing demography of BengalHealth Secretary meets Google's Chief Health Officer on sidelines of WHO Assembly at GenevaThou Shalt HearCouncil for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences launches 'PRAGATI-2024' to shape future of AyurvedaDoT, NTPRIT conduct Workshop for 220+ Sanchar Mitras from 20 StatesDST organises Climate Change Conclave at IIT, DelhiMeitY organises workshop on 'Powering Transformation through UI/UX for Digital Governance'Gujarat Govt launches drive against non-compliant gaming zonesI-T- In assessment order reasons have to be given as to why explanation of assesssee is not acceptable : HCArmy Major Radhika Sen to get UN Award for gender advocacyI-T- Additions framed u/s 69A on account of unexplained money, not tenable where source of cash is properly explained by assessee: ITATHouston is America’s dirtiest city: StudyPutin sounds alert to West against their weapons landing in RussiaI-T- An expenditure cannot be disallowed solely because the AO opines such expense to be very large or because some vouchers were not available: ITATUS not to cut military aid to Israel even after Rafah tragedyGST - Cancellation of registration - SCN and order are bereft of any details; cannot be sustained: HCMelinda Gates contributes USD one billion to promote women’s issuesArvind Kejriwal seeks extension of bail; SC bench re-directs Delhi CM towards CJIGST - Neither the show cause notice, nor the order spell out the reasons for retrospective cancellation - SCN and order are set aside - Registration is restored: HC17 stone quarry workers tragically lose lives in Mizoram amid heavy rainsNew rules for driving license - no more driving test at RTOs after June 1, 2024
 
Selection of Members for Revenue Boards : You show me the face, I show you the Rule!

By TIOL Edit Team

EVOLVING a new system to improve the tax administration is really creditable for any Government of the day. But what amounts to a notable achievable with long-term intrinsic value even for the posterity is its successful implementation with minimal exceptions. But, what appears to be happening in the case of selection of Members for the Revenue Boards is that a new system has been created to generate as many exceptions as to make them nothing less than the general rule! And what should be the general rule has become a glaring exception! Though Mr K Rangabhashyam is a fine revenue officer with outstanding achievements but he was overlooked by the North Block topbrass and also the Committee of Secretaries on the sole ground that he was left with less than one-year tenure. And since it was decided at the top echelons of the Government that to make meaningful contribution to the tax system a Member must have at least one year tenure.

Now, the very raison de'tre of this new selection criterion is awfully defeated if the MoF topbrass goes for those who have got less than one-year-tenure. No doubt, if our bureaucracy is asked to justify such exceptions no system in the world can beat it. Like in the case of Mr Rangabhashyam, one senior officer confided that his selection has been made against the vacancy for which Mr S Talwar's name was forwarded. But since his name was not cleared due to various reasons, the eligibility of Mr Rangabhashyam was to be calculated from the date of the post falling vacant. And this way he gets one year. No doubt, there are many chinks in this argument and Mr Rangabhashyam gets selected but such a selection methodology defeats the very purpose of the new tenure system.

It would certainly have been better to stick to the earlier system if one has to work only for a few months in the Boards as it also had a few very good Chief Commissioners lined up for the Member posts but they missed the bus in terms of their age. True, the duo of Dr Manmohan Singh and Mr P Chidambaram did not wish for such a system which appears to be advocating ''you show me the face, I show you the rule'.

Since we are here talking about the growing mess in the tax administration, the story would be incomplete if we overlook the festering mess in the CBEC. If we skip the most-disputed and complicated treatise of seniority list (a pandora's box) we cannot ignore the mess perpetrated in the recently held DPC of Chief Commissioners. Though the DoP&T and the ACC are very clear in their directions that the DPC should not be held in a piecemeal fashion and advance planning must be done to ensure continutity in the system and also not to deny promotion in time.

But CBEC simply and perhpas gently ignored all such diktats and went on to hold DPC for only eight vacancies corresponding to March 31, 2005, deadline. Had they done proper homework they could have held the same sometime in April and May for vacancies cropping up during the entire fiscal of 2005-06. But they went ahead for reasons best known to them.

But how poor was their homework behind this DPC done in, if not unholy, then holy haste, could be gauged from the fact that the panel of prospective Chief Commissioners also had the name of a retired official! And as a result, one of the officers who could have been covered was denied his promotion. Now a review DPC is expected to be held on April 1! But since it would be spilling over to the next fiscal, once again this would be violative of the DoP&T and ACC guidelines to work out the entire vacancy position for the fiscal and then go for DPC. Even UPSC will have a valid ground not to go for such piecemeal DPC.

All these episodes indeed call for better planning, transparency and non-discriminatory selection policy which should instil confidence and trust among honest and dedicated officers who never learnt the art of lobbying but could still get their dues. If our system fails to do it, a high morale coupled with integrity would certainly be a major casualty in the field formations!


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri N K Singh, recipient of TIOL FISCAL HERITAGE AWARD 2023, delivering his acceptance speech at Fiscal Awards event held on April 6, 2024 at Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi.


Shri Ram Nath Kovind, Hon'ble 14th President of India, addressing the gathering at TIOL Special Awards event.