News Update

Uttarakhand Govt cancels manufacturing licence of 14 products of PatanjaliIMF okays USD 1.1 bn bail-out package for Pakistan3 police officers killed in shoot-out in CarolinaGaza protesters on Columbia Univ campus turn tin-eared to police warningsBus swings into gorge; 25 Peruvians killedBattle against cocaine cartel: 9 Colombian soldiers perish in copter crashIndian Coast Guard on prowl; seizes 173 kg drugs from Indian fishing boat; 2 arrestedCus - High Courts are barred from hearing appeals involving issues of valuation of imported goods; appeals dismissed as not maintainable: HCIBC - When one party owes debt to another and creditor is claiming under written agreement providing for rendering 'service', debt is operational debt if claim of debt has some connection with service : SC (See 'TIOLCorplaws')SC stays HC order directing CBI to probe against WB officials’ role in teachers’ recruitment scamICG seizes 86 kg narcotics worth Rs 600 crore9 killed as two vehicles ram into each other in ChhattisgarhChief of Defence Staff Gen Anil Chauhan concludes his official visit to FranceConsumer court orders Swiggy to compensate for failure to deliver Ice CreamRequisite Checks for Appeals - Court FeeThe 'taxing' story of Malabar Parota, calories notwithstanding!I-T - Unless a case of bias, fraud or malice is alleged, then Department cannot assail SETCOM's order: HCCentre allows export of 99,150 MT onion to Bangladesh, UAE, Bhutan, Bahrain, Mauritius & LankaPension Portals of all Pension Disbursing Banks to be integratedI-T- Resolution Plan under IBC, once approved, nullifies any claims pertaining to a period prior to approval of said Plan: HC
 
What do judges do during summer vacation?

JUNE 06, 2005

By Justice R K Abichandani, CESTAT President

LIKE in Schools, we have a long summer vacation, Many such uneventful vacations had passed by and every succeeding one looked like any of the previous ones. The monotony had to be broken. On the eve of this Summer Vacation by a mere look in the mirror the obvious struck me by its conspicuous absence. For many years I had indulged in amusing myself at the cost of many a moustache, a hairy growth on a man's upper lip which I refused to allow with a daily dexterity. Since the growth is peculiar to man, the inner self revolted at its absence persuading the mind to give a try, and, the five weeks of absence from place of work was enough to hide the intervening embarrassment. The determination was kept secret but on the third day a reprimand came from close quarters for not shaving. Apologetically and rather sheepishly the plan was disclosed followed by a rare determination which was a result of the courage that the growth inspired. After all it was a man's privilege.

A couple of more agonizing days brought about the solution, a stealthy use of mascara which can be recommended only if you can keep a distance. The mirror reflected the ultimate look; and, far away from home in the hilly surroundings, there was no fear of retaliation from friends whose similar growth had drawn my attention and comment which of course did not offend. One such indiscretion is worthy of mention. A senior and respected colleague had a very prominent moustache carefully sported over the years on a sturdy face. More than 20 years after his elevation to the coveted post the look had remained the same and equally dark. One fine day working with him, I drew his attention to the fact that after his heading the institution, there was a marked increase in the clan of moustache growers particularly, the youth. By a serene and mature look, I was asked whether any of our colleagues had similarly ventured. A good old friend with a permanent youngish face held out his prominent moustache in the minds' eye and I drew the attention of the senior colleague to the fact that he was in good company of at least one of us. The difference, however, I could not resist to emphasize. In one case it was the moustache that was on the face while in the other it was as if the face was on the moustache. This dig had made me acutely aware to the proportion aspect of it now.

Nearly a fortnight passed away and with the new achievement which was without getting any help or encouragement I victoriously landed back bringing along some beautiful plants from the hilly nurseries. The first thing to be done was to attempt a pleasant surprise among our own Kith and Kin. Therefore, the very next day which was Sunday, I promptly proceeded to my parents� house and was respectfully greeted by the younger brother who had no comment to offer because of the age difference. His daughter, a seven year old kid on whom I banked for appreciation, emerged from inside and gave a startled look. Without anything more she started with agonizing shrieks and promptly declared that I was looking very bad. I consoled her by saying that this was the first time she had seen them on my face and it takes time to get used to new things in life. Often the progressive ideas are initially frowned upon. To take her mind off from the trauma, I asked her to give me a glass of cold water to drink. She seized this opportunity to bargain it out and said that she will get me the water provided I instantly remove my moustache. She was pointing in the direction of the place where my brother's shaving kit was kept which reminded me that my father also used to keep it there. I looked away into the hanging frame of my father and could perceive his smile, the one he always used to give when I did exactly what I wanted to.

Today, after the five weeks of marching ahead, feeling somewhat defeated and discouraged I am thinking of restoring the status quo ante, despite some messages of sympathy and encouragement. The better half who had remained diplomatically non-committal, when asked, opined that I should keep it for sometime since I had taken so much trouble and grown it. The garden plants which I had lovingly brought from the cold regions were about to wither away in the uneasy climate of these plains.

(The views expressed are strictly personal)


 RECENT DISCUSSION(S) POST YOUR COMMENTS
   
 
Sub: I "know" what you did last summer


At first glance, what came to my mind was the spooky Hollywood film by an almost similar sounding name but upon poring through the excellent and short piece, I found a new hue to what is commonly perceived of a high-ranking official.

We, the hoi polloi, usually tend to associate such officials with high handedness and their articles as sermons in their field of dominance.

The piece, therefore, came as whiff of fresh air, breezy enough to rejuvenate you and make you crave for more of such “discursive essays” which were the hall-mark of the country's greatest English language writer R.K.Narayan.

Hope to read more of such delightful and enchanting essays in the day's to come.

Respected Sir, it would be all the more pleasing to read the judgments delivered by you carry this trademark style rather than continue reading the generally mundane and the occasional brilliant stuff delivered by the Mumbai bench of the CESTAT.

As far as the mustachio goes, I think the following quote aptly sums it up.

From a man's face, I can read his character; of I can see him walk, I know his thoughts. - Petronius, Satyricon.

sunil achutan


Posted by
 
Sub: AJudge'syore

Sir,
A master piece from a Master of language. Some organisations benefit out of the men who chair them. Some men benefit out of the organisations they are in. Whether in or out, the CESTAT's President IS THE GIFT to our dull Tribunals. Let his wisdom brings out a refreshing change in the functioning of CESTAT. Good wishes, Sir.
By,
M.RAM KUMAR,
BANGALORE

Posted by ramkumar ramkumar
 
Sub: Insights into the mind of a legal luminary

The article is an insight into the mind of a legal luminary,the Honourable President of the CESTAT.
The article is masterfully written and carries in it a sense of humour told in an easy and truthful manner.
I really liked it.
I hope we get a series of such beautiful articles on what the Honourable Judges do during the summer vacations.

R K Jain,IRS(CCE)(IAS 1975 Exam-IC&CES 1976 Batch)
Commissioner,Central Excise,Ccustoms & Service Tax, South Kerala
Trivandrum

Posted by ravindrajain ravindrajain
 
Sub: What do judges do during summer

I was very delighted to read the article.I was happy to find the same to be a piece Literature and for a while I thought I was reading one of my P.G.Woodehouse Collectons.Having gone through similar experiences of growing the Moustache and the Beard never could pen down the same so touchingly.
Hats Off to You Sir
Sanjay Parelkar JDR CESTAT Mumbai

Posted by
 

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri N K Singh, recipient of TIOL FISCAL HERITAGE AWARD 2023, delivering his acceptance speech at Fiscal Awards event held on April 6, 2024 at Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi.


Shri Ram Nath Kovind, Hon'ble 14th President of India, addressing the gathering at TIOL Special Awards event.