News Update

CII projects 7.7% growth in current fiscalDRI nabs two persons with about 6 kg ivoryIBBI Chief calls for preserving reputation of fledgling institutionService Matter - Relief to Ashok Aggarwal - Disciplinary authority cannot approve initiation of enquiry by ignoring statements of witnesses and merely relying on gist of evidence forwarded by CBI: HCCCI invites public comments on merger of Linde & Praxaire-Way Bill for Intra-State movement of goods - State tally goes up to 27PM inaugurates Delhi-Meerut ExpresswayTax benefits to angel investors - CBDT inserts Clause (Viib) in Sec 56India generates 940 tonnes of plastic waste every day: Dr Harsh VardhanAnti-dumping duty imposed on ‘Saturated Fatty Alcohols' imported from Indonesia, Malaysia and ThailandGovt stipulates 8.5% interest rate on PFRule 11UA - Word 'or an accountant' omitted + Clause (viib) of Section 56(2) not to apply to consideration received by a Company for issue of shares that exceeds face value of such shares if received from an investorI-T - Taxable event arises as soon as interest income on bank deposits accrues & becomes due; Deferred receipts on instruction of depositor will not make it hypothetical income: HCFM is out of ICU; recovering fast after kidney transplantAnti-dumping duty on on'Ammonium Nitrate' - Notification 44/2017-Cus(ADD) amended to substitute name of exporter at sr. no.1 as 'Euro Chem Trading GMBH Through Rawfert Offshore Sal, Lebanon'Finance Commission team to visit Kerala on coming MondayWTO Chief calls for reducing trade tensionsNIC cloud-based data centre to go live in OrissaCBIC clarifies on application of IGST on goods supplied while deposited in Customs bonded warehousePublic comments sought on Draft NDCP till June 1, 2018PM lays foundation stone for Patratu Super Power ProjectI-T - It is not open for AO to make additions while framing assessment u/s 143(3) merely on basis of seized documents beyond period of limitation u/s 153A: ITATIndia to rope in international labs for food testingISC Panel finalises recommendations of Punchhi CommissionCBIC introduces monetary limits of Rs.2.50 lakhs for filing Revenue appeals before Commissioner(A); applicable to CX & ST legacy cases and those currently pending.Govt sanctions out of turn coal to PSUs; Private plants find themselves at receiving endACC appoints JS, TRU, Alok Shukla as Minister (Customs) in PMI to WTO at GenevaACC grants one more year extension to CBDT Chairman Sushil ChandraThere is no provision in the CGSTAct which allows exemption on an Input Service if the Output service provided by taxable service is exempt: AARServices provided to M/s Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Ltd. – since it is company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, and not a State Government authority, benefit of concessional rate @12% not available: AARServices provided of diagnosis, pre and post counseling therapy qualify to be health care services and attract Nil rate of Tax: AARTransaction of transfer of one of the units of the applicant as a going concern amounts to supply of service – Nil rate under 12/2017-CT(R): AAR
GST fails exporters - needs overhaul

NOVEMBER 03, 2017

By Dinesh Kumar Agrawal, Executive Director, Khaitan & Co, Mumbai

RAPID growth of exports leads to higher economic growth and generate employment opportunities and, therefore, successive Indian governments have taken measures to promote export. One of the fundamental principles to promote export is "export goods but not the taxes", and, therefore, most of the exports are zero-rated.In the pre-GST regime of multi-layered multiple tax, it was difficult to accurately assess central, state and local taxes embedded in the exports. GST subsumed almost all indirect taxes under a single levy and, therefore, it was expected that under GST regime, exports would be "nearly" zero-rated. Nearly because electricity and petroleum fuels are still outside GST.

Export of goods and services are zero-rated under Section 16 of the IGST Act and the exporter can opt for any of the following methods for refund of taxes:

(a) Option-I: Supply goods or services under bond or Letter of Undertaking (LUT), without payment of integrated tax and claim refund of unutilised input tax credit (ITC); or

(b) Option-II: Supply goods or services on payment of integrated tax and claim refund of such tax paid thereon.

Zero-rating of tax paid on Capital goods:

Section 54 of the CGST Act provides for refund of unutilised ITC only if exports were made without payment of tax. A person can take credit of taxes paid on inward supplies of capital goods, inputs and input services. However, under GST Rule 89(4), only inputs and input services are considered for computation of refund amount. Thus, tax paid on capital goods is not zero-rated under first option, even if such capital goods has been exclusively used in processing of export goods. Under the second option, an exporter can export goods on payment of tax and seek refund thereof. Tax can be paid through electronic credit ledger without any restriction on credit taken on capital goods. Thus, tax paid on capital goods is zero-rated only under the second option.

Every exporter must invest in plant and machinery to manufacture and process goods or service for export. Such capital goods are subjected to GST. CVD exemptions given under EPCG Scheme and EOU scheme has been withdrawn under GST era. Thus, every exporter opting for the first option must bear the tax cost of capital goods which gets embedded in the exports. On the other hand, exporter opting for the second option can reclaim the tax paid on capital goods. Disparity between the two options is unwarranted and exporters must be allowed refund of tax paid on capital goods used in export.

Working capital blockage:

Initially Government had mandated for acceptance of LUT only for exporters with established export performance (status holder or export earnings of Rs.1 crore in the previous year) and others were mandated to execute bond with bank guarantee. As furnishing bank guarantee increased transaction cost and blockage of working capital, in a welcome move, the government relaxed the norms and permitted all exporters with unblemished records to furnish LUT.

However, to the dismay of exporters,refund process is yet to be enabled in the GSTN portal even after 4 months of GST rollout. It may be noted that Section 54 of the CGST Act permits immediate disbursement of 90% of the refund claim but it seems that lethargic implementation of system has taken its toll on the exporters.

To relieve exporters, recently Government has substantially reduced GST rate for penultimate supply of goods for export @0.1%. Similarly, supplies have been allowed to claim refund of tax paid on supply of goods to EOU, and against EPCG or advance authorisation. However, in view of the delay in disbursement of refund, suppliers are unlikely to accommodate exporters.


GST was supposed to encourage export but it has proved to be a big dampener. Exporters need higher working capital and forgo refund on capital goods. Government has asked Group to Ministers to suggest measures for exporters.

I believe that following measures will provide requisite relief to the exporters:

(i) Tax paid on capital goods should form part of zero-rating. Government may like to refund tax paid on capital goods in staggered manner and, therefore, may restrict amount of refund to the output tax payable on exports. Alternatively, credit attributable to a tax period on capital goods for zero-rating may be determined by applying GST Rule 43.

(ii) Ab-initio exemptions must be restored under EOU, EOU, EPCG and advance authorisation. Deemed export should also be zero-rated.

(iii) Government must provisionally disburse refund claim of ITC equal to old duty drawback amount and adjust the same at the time of regular ITC refund under Section 54 of the CGST Act.

(iv) Bond/LUT by the service exporters must be dispensed with.

(The views expressed are strictly personal.)

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)


Sub: GST

Good article.

Posted by Samir Sinha