News Update

For rains-ravaged Kerala 'relief' calls pour in; Customs explains proceduresMultiple personality Order - Implications and way forward!Customs Brokers and their woesST - Respondent cannot take shelter under a faulty software programme when they themselves handled system - Penalty u/s 78 of FA, 1994 wrongly set aside by CESTAT: High CourtBudget Allocation of Rs 2875 Cr - CBIC not happy with trend of spending less!I-T - Once trademark acquired is used for selling products, its eligibility for depreciation cannot be questioned, simply because trademark is not put to use for manufacturing activities: HCRecasting base year for GDP - Govt mulling over various alternativesFlood-battered Kerala - Cabinet Secretary-headed NCMC calls for shifting focus on supplies of food, water, medicines, power, fuel and telecom servicesIndia successfully test-fires 'Helina', copter-based anti-tank guided missile + also test-fires guided bombs smart anti-airfield weapon systemGovt yet to firm up mind for back-casting of GDP series; Various alternatives under considerationMulti-modal transport - TIR Convention comes into forceJalandhar CGST Commissionerate is first to become e-OfficeAadhaar Regulator to launch phased introduction of face recognition features from Sept 15Walmart wraps up Flipkart acquisition formalities; Current management to run operationsFormer UN Chief Kofi Annan passes away at 80DRI, Police & para-military forces seize 78 drums of ganja, heroin & tabletsKerala CM says worst flood in 100 years; PM announces Rs 500 Cr immediate reliefWorld Humanitarian Day - UN urges global leaders to protect people caught in conflictST - Tribunal has relied upon speech of Finance Minister for holding that assessee was not liable to pay tax without discussing relevant provisions of law/notifications - Matter remanded: HCAdvance Ruling - a nightmare for taxpayers?I-T - Exemption u/s 10(23C)(iv) can be claimed only to the extent of actual income and not for accumulated income: ITATSection 197 Certificate - CBDT proposes to amend Rules to make it electronicImport of Pet Coke allowed for only cement, lime kiln, calcium carbide and gasification Industries, when used as feed stock/manufacturing process on Actual User ConditionCBDT puts in abeyance controversial clauses relating to GAAR & GSTEvery 1% growth in mining industry soars up industrial production index by 1.5%, says FICCIRailways launches 'Digital Screens' at 22 Stations
 
NDA Govt plays politically safe; shuns major fiscal reforms

APRIL 23, 2018

By TIOL Edit Team

THE Finance Ministry has frittered away a rare opportunity to undertake fiscal reforms as mooted by successive Finance Commissions, FRBM Review Committee (FRBMRC) and CAG.

This is the unmistakable conclusion anyone would arrive at after reading Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (Amendment) Rules, 2018 notified on 2 nd April. The reading has to be coupled with reference to amendments to FRBM Act 2003 undertaken through Finance Act, 2018.

Instead of enacting a new law , NDA Government has tinkered with FRBM Act and rules as done by previous Governments to accommodate their political compulsions. The latest tinkering is however, a blend of both good and bad amendments .

The commendable goals incorporated as amendment to FRBM Act is a resolve to ensure that the 1) the country's total Government debt does not exceed 60% of gross domestic product (GDP) & 2) the Central Government debt does not exceed 40% of GDP by the end of financial year 2024-2025.

FRBMRC had recommended that 60% cap on India's total government debt should be achieved in 2022-23 by phased reduction in borrowings.

Another good amendment is the provision to give inkling about proposed changes in taxes and expenditure in the coming years .This disclosure has to be made in Medium Term Fiscal Policy cum Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement.

As put by FRBM (Amendment) Rules, 2018, “major changes proposed to be introduced in direct and indirect taxes in the ensuing financial year will be presented. It (Statement) shall contain an assessment of income tax exemption limits and how far it relates to per capita income, principles regarding tax exemptions and target group for exemptions ".

The new Rules require the Ministry to "specify the tax-GDP ratio for the current year and subsequent two years with an assessment of the changes required for achieving it ".

According to the Rules, "It may discuss the non-tax revenues and the policies concerning the same. An assessment of the capital receipts may be made, including the borrowings and other liabilities, as per policies spelt out. The Statementmay also give projections for GDP and discuss it on the basis of assumptions underlying the indicators. Expenditure on revenue account may also be made with particular emphasis on the measures proposed to meet the overall objectives ".

The deplorable amendment is the removal of revenue deficit (RD) as a statutory deficit indicator and the consequent requirement of specifying yearly targets for phased elimination of RD. The original target for elimination of RD by 31 st March 2008 as stipulated by FRBM Act 2003 was deferred repeatedly through subsequent amendments.

The trashing of a statutory target that could never be achieved makes a mockery of fiscal discipline. RD would, henceforth be merely reported as percentage of GDP for record and reference only as would be the primary deficit as percentage of GDP.

The Amendment, leading to removal of effective RD (ERD) as statutory indicator is in keeping with the recommendation of fourteenth Finance Commission (FFC). Incorporated in 2012 through an amendment to FRBM Act, ERD was considered as creative budgeting tool by FFC. It had thus recommended its removal.

With this, the only statutory deficit indicator is fiscal deficit (FD).

According to FRBM (Amendment) Rules 2018, the Central Government shall reduce FD by an amount equivalent to 0.1 per cent or more of GDP at the end of each financial year beginning with the financial year 2018-19, so that FD isbrought down to not more than 3 per cent of the GDP by 31st day of March, 2021.

It is shocking to find that successive governments have not moved beyond the 3% FD and have instead kept pushing this goalpost to suit their fiscal laxity. This 3% FD target was to be achieved by 31 st March 2008 as envisaged under FRBM Rules 2004.

FD & RD targets, as recommended by FCs,FRBMRC and other similar panels, have perhaps never been complied with by the Government of the day.

One can't make a head or tail of latest amendments to FRBM Act and rules without referring back and forth to original enactment and rules and subsequent amendments.

The Ministry must end this fiscal obfuscation by enacting a new FRBM Act and framing new rules. It might well stick to sum and substance of the existing framework. Simplicity of legal framework is a pre-requisite for assessing compliance with the law.

The Governmentalso ought to take the nation into confidence for its decision to not act on FRBMRC's recommendation to repeal the present law and introduce a new legislation captioned ‘The Debt Management and Fiscal Responsibility Bill, 2017'.

It should also explain why it overlooked FFC's similar recommendation to "replace the existing FRBM Act with a Debt Ceiling and Fiscal Responsibility Legislation, specifically invoking Article 292 in its preamble. This could be an alternative to amending the existing FRBM Act as proposed by us. We urge the State Governments also to consider similar enactments under Article 293(1)."

The Government also owes an explanation to the nation for its reluctance to constitute an independent fiscal council, recommended by both FC and FRBMRC.

At the global level, Fiscal council is today deemed as benchmark for fiscal accountability and compliance by governments. As many as 39 countries had constituted such bodies by December 2016.

We hope the Government would introspect over the implications of India being saddled with first-generation fiscal rulesand for its reluctance to independent assessment of its compliance with fiscal rules.


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

Legal Wrangle | GST | Episode 80

What's New

CGST Rule Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
IGST Rate Notification
UTGST Rate Notification
Cess Rate Notification
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
CBDT Order - IT Return  
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
Excise - Instruction  
Service Tax Circular
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

TAXATION & WILDLIFE



wso shell wso shell Indoxploit Shell wso shell hacklink hacklink satışı hacklink deface mirror hacklink satış wso shell