News Update

Monetary limits - CBDT amends Circular to 'fight it out'For rains-ravaged Kerala 'relief' calls pour in; Customs explains proceduresMultiple personality Order - Implications and way forward!Customs Brokers and their woesST - Respondent cannot take shelter under a faulty software programme when they themselves handled system - Penalty u/s 78 of FA, 1994 wrongly set aside by CESTAT: High CourtBudget Allocation of Rs 2875 Cr - CBIC not happy with trend of spending less!I-T - Once trademark acquired is used for selling products, its eligibility for depreciation cannot be questioned, simply because trademark is not put to use for manufacturing activities: HCRecasting base year for GDP - Govt mulling over various alternativesFlood-battered Kerala - Cabinet Secretary-headed NCMC calls for shifting focus on supplies of food, water, medicines, power, fuel and telecom servicesIndia successfully test-fires 'Helina', copter-based anti-tank guided missile + also test-fires guided bombs smart anti-airfield weapon systemGovt yet to firm up mind for back-casting of GDP series; Various alternatives under considerationMulti-modal transport - TIR Convention comes into forceJalandhar CGST Commissionerate is first to become e-OfficeAadhaar Regulator to launch phased introduction of face recognition features from Sept 15Walmart wraps up Flipkart acquisition formalities; Current management to run operationsFormer UN Chief Kofi Annan passes away at 80DRI, Police & para-military forces seize 78 drums of ganja, heroin & tabletsKerala CM says worst flood in 100 years; PM announces Rs 500 Cr immediate reliefWorld Humanitarian Day - UN urges global leaders to protect people caught in conflictST - Tribunal has relied upon speech of Finance Minister for holding that assessee was not liable to pay tax without discussing relevant provisions of law/notifications - Matter remanded: HCAdvance Ruling - a nightmare for taxpayers?I-T - Exemption u/s 10(23C)(iv) can be claimed only to the extent of actual income and not for accumulated income: ITATSection 197 Certificate - CBDT proposes to amend Rules to make it electronicImport of Pet Coke allowed for only cement, lime kiln, calcium carbide and gasification Industries, when used as feed stock/manufacturing process on Actual User ConditionCBDT puts in abeyance controversial clauses relating to GAAR & GSTEvery 1% growth in mining industry soars up industrial production index by 1.5%, says FICCIRailways launches 'Digital Screens' at 22 Stations
 
When Domestic Tax Laws Reach Beyond Customs Frontiers

 

APRIL 25, 2018

By Neeladri Chakrabarti, Corporate Lead, Indirect Tax, CMC Limited

INDIA has slowly become an emerging market for exports and a plethora of industries and institutions have set up shop in the country promoting the business and earning foreign exchange for the country. The Government, recognizing this trend, has from time to time introduced various schemes to incentivize export, purportedly to streamline the flow of foreign exchange, and to make the export industry competitive in the international market.

However, after the Goods and Services Act(s) have been introduced in 2017, a peculiar situation has developed in relation to exports. In the previous regime of taxation, Section 66B of the Finance Act (w.e.f. 1 July 2012), provided in the charging section that all services provided or sought to be provided in the taxable territory were liable to Service tax. Taxable territory was defined as the whole of India except the state of Jammu and Kashmir. The Place of Provision of Service Rules, 2012 (POPS) read with Section 66C of the aforesaid Finance Act determined the situs of service and where this place of provision was outside the taxable territory, no Service tax was payable under Section 66B, even if the service did not fulfil all the conditions relating to export of service. Similarly, in the case of Central Sales Tax and Value Added Tax, sale of goods that took place beyond the customs frontiers of India were not exigible to tax, as they were considered to be taking place outside the taxable territory.

Fast forward to the GST regime, where the place of supply (under Section 12 and 13 of the IGST Act) is ostensibly required only to determine location and identify the tax to be paid. Further, the IGST Act (Section 7) makes it clear that even when the supplier is in India, and the place of supply is outside India, the supply istreated as an inter-state supply. Thus, it follows that unlike the previous regime, where only situs determined taxability; in the GST regime, the Acts have extended to negate this concept possibly to extract maximum taxable revenue from supplies made by exporters.

This peculiarity is now manifest in prevailing transactions that were previously exempt in the erstwhile taxation regime. In the recent advance ruling in re: M/s Rod Retail Private Limited - 2018-TIOL-08-AAR-GST the Authority for Advance Ruling in New Delhi has taken a narrow view on what supplies constitute "export" and has given a somewhat contentious ruling. The AAR while determining whether supply from duty free shops were "zero rated" for the purpose of export has held that supply of goods to international passengers from the said 'Duty Free' shops, located in the security hold of the international airport, may be taking place beyond the customs frontiers of India, however, since the said shops were within the territory of India under the CGST Act, the said supply was not tantamount to export and hence were liable to GST.

The AAR held that the goods could qualify as export only after they crossed the territorial waters of India and the situs of being outside the Customs frontiers of India had no bearing on the transaction to determine export. Section 2(5) of the IGST Act 2017, which determines export of goods, clearly states that taking goods out of India to a place outside India fulfils the condition of export. "India" is defined under Section 2(56) of the CGST Act as the territory of India including its territorial waters, seabed, sub soil, EEZ, Continental Shelf and the air space above its territory and territorial waters.

It was not in dispute that the duty free shop was situated beyond the Customs Frontiers of India. However, the issue in the present case was whether the said duty free shop was outside the territory of India i.e. whether it was "beyond the territory, airspace or territorial waters of India". Since this condition was not fulfilled, the said supply was made exigible to GST at the hands of the supplier. The situs of the supplier, outside the customs frontier of India, was deemed to be immaterial and adistinction between the customs frontiers of India and territorial waters of India was bought into sharp focus in this constrictive interpretation of the law by the AAR.

In an emerging market, where Indian businesses need to be fiercely competitive to foreign markets, this ruling handicaps duty free shops as they are now brought at par with their peers inside the customs frontier. Since these shops have been consistent earners of foreign exchange for the country, it begs the question whether this handicap, which appears to be a result of judicious use of red tape and bureaucracy, was really warranted? Especially in light of the fact that now foreign exchange inflow will be impacted as customers may prefer to do their business inside the frontier due to negation of the competitive advantage.

(The views expressed are strictly personal.)

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and Taxindiaonline.com doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Taxindiaonline.com Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)

POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

Legal Wrangle | GST | Episode 80

What's New

CGST Rule Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
IGST Rate Notification
UTGST Rate Notification
Cess Rate Notification
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
CBDT Order - IT Return  
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
Excise - Instruction  
Service Tax Circular
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

TAXATION & WILDLIFE



wso shell wso shell Indoxploit Shell wso shell hacklink hacklink satışı hacklink deface mirror hacklink satış wso shell