News Update

Monetary limits - CBDT amends Circular to 'fight it out'For rains-ravaged Kerala 'relief' calls pour in; Customs explains proceduresMultiple personality Order - Implications and way forward!Customs Brokers and their woesST - Respondent cannot take shelter under a faulty software programme when they themselves handled system - Penalty u/s 78 of FA, 1994 wrongly set aside by CESTAT: High CourtBudget Allocation of Rs 2875 Cr - CBIC not happy with trend of spending less!I-T - Once trademark acquired is used for selling products, its eligibility for depreciation cannot be questioned, simply because trademark is not put to use for manufacturing activities: HCRecasting base year for GDP - Govt mulling over various alternativesFlood-battered Kerala - Cabinet Secretary-headed NCMC calls for shifting focus on supplies of food, water, medicines, power, fuel and telecom servicesIndia successfully test-fires 'Helina', copter-based anti-tank guided missile + also test-fires guided bombs smart anti-airfield weapon systemGovt yet to firm up mind for back-casting of GDP series; Various alternatives under considerationMulti-modal transport - TIR Convention comes into forceJalandhar CGST Commissionerate is first to become e-OfficeAadhaar Regulator to launch phased introduction of face recognition features from Sept 15Walmart wraps up Flipkart acquisition formalities; Current management to run operationsFormer UN Chief Kofi Annan passes away at 80DRI, Police & para-military forces seize 78 drums of ganja, heroin & tabletsKerala CM says worst flood in 100 years; PM announces Rs 500 Cr immediate reliefWorld Humanitarian Day - UN urges global leaders to protect people caught in conflictST - Tribunal has relied upon speech of Finance Minister for holding that assessee was not liable to pay tax without discussing relevant provisions of law/notifications - Matter remanded: HCAdvance Ruling - a nightmare for taxpayers?I-T - Exemption u/s 10(23C)(iv) can be claimed only to the extent of actual income and not for accumulated income: ITATSection 197 Certificate - CBDT proposes to amend Rules to make it electronicImport of Pet Coke allowed for only cement, lime kiln, calcium carbide and gasification Industries, when used as feed stock/manufacturing process on Actual User ConditionCBDT puts in abeyance controversial clauses relating to GAAR & GSTEvery 1% growth in mining industry soars up industrial production index by 1.5%, says FICCIRailways launches 'Digital Screens' at 22 Stations
 
I-T - Sec 54EC benefits cannot be denied if delay in investment of capital gains was on account of non-availability of tax-free bonds: ITAT

By TIOL News Service

NEW DELHI, MAY 16, 2018: THE ISSUE IS - Whether failure to purchase Rural Electrification Bonds before specified time limit of six months from the date of aquiring capital gain, will debar the investor from seeking exemption u/s 54EC if such failure was on account of non availability of bonds in the market. NO IS THE ANSWER.

Facts of the case:

The assessee, an individual, had sold his land situated at Village Bakkarwala, Delhi to M/s Prabhu Ram Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. for a consideration of Rs.1,80,20,833/- in which the assessee had 1/3rd share. The assessee's share came to Rs.60,06,944/- and after allowing the indexed cost of acquisition, the long term capital gains worked out to Rs.41,39,905/-. The assessee claimed that he had purchased capital gain tax exemption bonds issued by the Rural Electrification Corporation Ltd. amounting to Rs.42 lakhs and claimed deduction u/s 54EC. However, the AO pointed out that the assessee had transferred his capital assets on Oct 10, 2006 and the investment for purchase of Rural Electrification bond were required to be made within six months from the transfer of capital assets. Since investment was made beyond this period, the AO did not allow the deduction u/s 54EC. On appeal, the disallowance made by the AO was upheld by the FAA.

On further appeal before the ITAT, the assessee took an additional ground that the land sold by him was not a capital asset and therefore, the capital gain arising on the transfer of land was not taxable. The Tribunal admitted the additional evidence and restored the issue to the file of AO. As the Tribunal had restored the specific issue of additional ground, the AO gave an opportunity to the assessee to submit evidence with regard to the claim that the land sold was not a capital asset. Hence, notice was issued to the assessee specifically asking him to furnish the evidence with regard to the distance of his land from the nearest municipal limit. But, the assessee failed to do so and accordingly, the AO held that transfer of land amounting to Rs.41,39,905/- was chargeable to tax.

During second round of appeal, the CIT(A) dismissed the assessee's contention on the ground that in view of the provisions of Sec. 2(14), the land sold by him fell within the scope of the term 'capital asset' since the said land was situated within the limit of municipal limit of Delhi and was within the jurisdiction of municipality and the land was not rural agricultural land. So far as argument of assessee that he had invested in Rural Electrification Bond u/s 54EC, the FAA held that this was already considered in earlier round of proceedings where he had upheld the disallowance made by AO.

Tribunal held that,

++ the issue that arises in the present appeal is regarding the benefit of deduction u/s 54EC on account of purchase of Rural Electrification Bonds after the specified time. In the present case, the assessee had sold the capital asset on Oct 25, 2006 and, therefore, for claiming deduction u/s 54EC, he should have made the investment on or before Apr 25, 2007 i.e. within six months from the date of earning of the capital gain. However, in the instant case, the assessee has invested in Rural Electrification Bonds on July 23, 2007. The submission of AR that the Rural Electrification Bonds were not available between Mar 31, 2007 to July 02, 2007 could not be controverted by the DR. Under these circumstances, it has to be adjudicated as to whether the assessee is entitled to deduction u/s 54EC when such bonds were not purchased during the time limit as prescribed u/s 54EC but were purchased subsequent to the date when such bonds were made available in the market;

++ it is found that the Pune Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Phansalkar Suman Jaikrishna, under identical facts and circumstances has allowed the claim of deduction u/s 54EC by observing that: "....Lex not cogit impossibila (law does not compel a man to do that which he cannot possibly perform) and impossibilum nulla oblignto est (law does not expect a party to do the impossible) are well known maxims in law and would squarely apply to the present case. The statue viz. Section 54EC provides for exemption from tax to long term capital gain provided the same is invested in bonds of Rural Electrification Corporation Limited or National Highway Authority of India. However, as the bonds were not available, it was impossible for the assessee to invest in them within six months of the sale of their factory building. Therefore, in the circumstance, one would have to interpret Section 54EC to ensure that it does not lead to injustice. Therefore, the six months provided for investing in bonds may be reasonably extended in view of the non availability of bonds...." Since in the instant case, the facts are identical to the facts decided by the Pune Bench, therefore, following the said decision, the assessee is entitled to deduction u/s 54EC.

(See 2018-TIOL-706-ITAT-DEL)


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

Legal Wrangle | GST | Episode 80

What's New

CGST Rule Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
IGST Rate Notification
UTGST Rate Notification
Cess Rate Notification
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
CBDT Order - IT Return  
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
Excise - Instruction  
Service Tax Circular
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

TAXATION & WILDLIFE



wso shell wso shell Indoxploit Shell wso shell hacklink hacklink satışı hacklink deface mirror hacklink satış wso shell