News Update

India, Oman resolve to expediate talks for DTAATight schedule for Monsoon Session - 46 bills to be passed in 24 daysGovt proposes to amend law for Fastags for all commercial vehiclesCBDT Instruction No 3/18 - Board asks CCITs to wrap up withdrawal of appeals by Aug 20, 2018I-T - If assessee fails to establish urgent nature of business necessities for taking loans from its Directors in cash, such transaction warrants levy of penalty u/s 271D: ITAT Special BenchOECD employment rate raises by 0.2% in Q1SC asks Parliament to enact new law to deal with mobocracyST - If GOI department could be treated as using 'Residential Complex' constructed by NBCC for its 'personal use', how another Corporate body could be denied benefit of that type of user of 'Residential Complex' to be occupied by its Managerial Staff: HCPlace of removal - Valuation under CE & Customs Laws - past and present (See 'TOG INSIGHT' on 'Taxongo.com')India mulling safeguard duty on Chinese and Malaysian solar panelsGovt hikes basic import duty on many textile goodsIMF says India to be fastest growing economy in 2019CBDT prescribes registration form for Non-resident applicantsIs disallowing supplementary claim under MEIS & SEIS Scheme by DGFT valid?CX - On being pointed out, Assessee immediately reversed Credit wrongly availed - there cannot be said to be any fraud through which it wanted to evade Duty - setting aside of interest & penalty cannot be faulted: HCIGST refund - CBIC launches another fortnightly drive till July 30I-T - Complaint received against assessee is a reason to suspect but it is not a reason to believe that some income has escaped assessment untill AO verifies content of information before initiating re-assessment: ITATWCO Secretary General lauds India's efforts to use technology for trade facilitationBrahMos successfully test-fired from Balasore Test RangeIndia-Oman Joint Commission Meeting begins in MuscatHi-tech maritime labs launching programmes for traineesChina's GDP logs 6.8% growth in first half of fiscal20 hurt in pandal collapse during PM's Midnapore political rallyExports - Accountability of inputs - DGFT eases norms for Advance Authorisation holdersCustoms - CBIC expands list of exempt items for handicraft sectorI-T - Even if soil separated from land and put in containers it continues to be specie of land and income from growing mushrooms in such containers under controlled environment is agri income exempt u/s 10(1): ITAT Special BenchWTO - Govt officials attend workshop on SPS control, Inspection & approval proceduresI-T - Surplus generated by agriculturist on sale of his agri land is no basis to deny exemption u/s 2(14) and treat sale consideration as business income: HCSecond Year of GST - A year to amend mistakesCommittee set up to examine 'decriminalisation' of offences under Companies Act
 
Replace 48 months Vs 48 yrs campaign with Poll Manifesto-linked Outcomes

MAY 31, 2018

By TIOL Edit Team

PRESENTATION of Report to the Nation is a solemn occasion. It is an opportunity for the Government of the day to measure progress, identify slippages and show the way forward. The opportunity gains added importance when Report is presented in the last year of Government's tenure.

Digitally-savvy NDA Government has thus set a new benchmark on this count. Instead of presenting a conventional Report, it has flooded Government websites with links to a special website https://48months.mygov.in/.

It is loaded with photo album, info graphics, ministers' blogs etc that exude Utopian dazzle end-to-end. The Website is also laced with positive sound bytes/videos from beneficiaries of Central Government's flagship schemes that begin with usual Pradhan Mantri tag.

The website contains info about focus areas. The unsaid focus of the whole performance report card is nevertheless Prime Minister Narendra Modi. No one has any doubt that he is the one when who brought BJP to power. Mr. Modi also brought several parties together to create National Democratic Alliance.

No one has right to question the presentation of achievements to reinforce the message that the Government has excelled on all counts.

So far so good. The has, however, a right to know how the Government performed against promises especially the ones embedded inelection manifesto and post-election NDA's agenda for governance or promises made after formation of the Government.

As NDA did not draft any agenda for collective performance, the citizens have no option but expect comparison of achievements against promises made in BJP's 2014 manifesto. Accounting of the fate of promises made by ministers would also be reasonable demand from public.

Citizens should, however, leave aside assurances made at the poll rallies. These are best left as forgotten electoral rhetoric or taken lightly as jumlas.

Instead of showcasing its achievements against Manifesto's promises, Modi Government/BJP wants public to compare its 48 months performance with Congress' 48 years record.

The tone for this comparison was set by Mr Modi himself on 25th February 2018. He reportedly stated: "One family either directly or indirectly ruled the country for 48 years," while referring to the governments of Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi and Rajiv Gandhi.

On the other hand, there was the NDA government that will complete 48 months this May. Intellectuals can debate the difference between what was achieved during the Congress regimes and the BJP-led NDA, he added.

Such comparison reeks of rancor against Nehru-Gandhi family. It can at best be taken as secondary and complex contrast between two non-comparable periods.

Non-comparable because 48-year period bristled with too many grave, external & internal challenges.

The foremost one was the partition and the resulting herculean challenges. Factor in 1962 Chinese aggression, 1965 Pakistan attack and 1971 Bangladesh war. All these involved colossal expenditure. This period witnessed strongest bouts of volatility in commodity prices especially of crude. The 48 years were also marked with fissiparous tendencies, insurgencies and communal and other riots. The country also had to cope with food crisis, droughts and floods.

Modi Government's 48months is built on platform built by toil and blood spent over the decades by previous regimes. The 48 months have been exceptionally benign on external front. The internal turmoil is far less severe than what was witnessed during 48 years. Monsoon has been exceptionally benign towards Modi Government.

Put simply, 48 months vs 48 years comparison has to be extremely exhaustive.

Do citizens want such academic exercise or want results from vote-mongers? Do voters want to live with hatred for the past or know what is in store from them, excluding the dream about New India 2022 - corruption and poverty-free India?

People first expect better and faster results from Modi Government on resolution of problems such as unemployment, water crisis, poverty and delayed justice.

The search for answers to such issues has to begin from BJP's manifesto. The Government should issue point-by-point comparison of performance against resolves contained in the Manifesto.

The Government should not be scared of admitting its failure to implement certain promises such as announcing new education policy (NEP).

The Manifesto stated: "BJP will set up a National Commission on Education to report in two years on the state of education and the reforms needed. Based on the report, BJP will implement a National Education Policy to meet the changing dynamics of the population's requirement with regards to quality education, innovation and research, aiming to make India a knowledge superpower by equipping its students with the necessary skills and knowledge and to eliminate the shortage of manpower in science, technology, academics and industry”.

The Government ought to take the Nation into confidence for the reasons for delays or its inability to proceed on a few promises. Good governance is not only marketing of achievements but also retaining trust of the public. And trust is sustained by transparency and accountability.

Once that happens in real sense and in ample measure, the public would automatically say the Government of the day has Saaf Niyat, Sahi Vikas .

Too much and too strident self-certification is not good governance. It creates credibility deficit.


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

GST 1st Anniversary - A Hardlook (Episode 2) | simply inTAXicating

What's New

CGST Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

TAXATION & WILDLIFE