News Update

Flood-battered Kerala - Cabinet Secretary-headed NCMC calls for shifting focus on supplies of food, water, medicines, power, fuel and telecom servicesIndia successfully test-fires ‘Helina’, copter-based anti-tank guided missile + also test-fires guided bombs smart anti-airfield weapon systemGovt yet to firm up mind for back-casting of GDP series; Various alternatives under considerationMulti-modal transport - TIR Convention comes into forceJalandhar CGST Commissionerate is first to become e-OfficeAadhaar Regulator to launch phased introduction of face recognition features from Sept 15Walmart wraps up Flipkart acquisition formalities; Current management to run operationsFormer UN Chief Kofi Annan passes away at 80DRI, Police & para-military forces seize 78 drums of ganja, heroin & tabletsKerala CM says worst flood in 100 years; PM announces Rs 500 Cr immediate reliefWorld Humanitarian Day - UN urges global leaders to protect people caught in conflictST - Tribunal has relied upon speech of Finance Minister for holding that assessee was not liable to pay tax without discussing relevant provisions of law/notifications - Matter remanded: HCAdvance Ruling - a nightmare for taxpayers?I-T - Exemption u/s 10(23C)(iv) can be claimed only to the extent of actual income and not for accumulated income: ITATSection 197 Certificate - CBDT proposes to amend Rules to make it electronicImport of Pet Coke allowed for only cement, lime kiln, calcium carbide and gasification Industries, when used as feed stock/manufacturing process on Actual User ConditionCBDT puts in abeyance controversial clauses relating to GAAR & GSTEvery 1% growth in mining industry soars up industrial production index by 1.5%, says FICCIAtalji cremated at Smriti Sthal with full state honoursRailways launches 'Digital Screens' at 22 StationsIndia wants FAO to declare upcoming years as 'International Year of Millets'Bird's eye view - Form 3CD amendmentsCBIC notifies Customs exchange rates effective from August 17, 2018Worsening flood conditions in Kerala; Centre discusses more measuresData Protection Bill - Govt seeks public comments by Sept 10, 2018Income Tax - Both ACIT as well as JCIT are competent officers for sanctioning issue of notice u/s 148: HCGST - Credit conundrums - Overlooking them is no solution!
 
I-T - Levy of same fees on identical assessees placed on similar footing, is no basis to judge exclusivity of such levy in terms of Section 40(a)(iib): HC

 

By TIOL News Service

ERNAKULAM, JUNE 13, 2018: THE ISSUE BEFORE THE HIGH COURT IS - Whether levy of same fees/charges on identical assessees placed on same footing, is no basis to judge exclusivity of such levy in terms of Section 40(a)(iib). YES IS THE VERDICT.

Facts of the case:

The assessee company is engaged in the business of Indian made foreign liquor. For the relevant A.Y, the self assessment in the case of assessee was completed after disallowing the deductions claimed by assessee towards (i) Gallonage fee amounting to Rs.54,83,87,000/-, (ii) Licence fee amounting to Rs.5,75,000/-, (iii) Shop license fee amounting to Rs.199,71,00,000/- and (iv) Surcharge on sales tax amounting to Rs.551,61,01,115/-, on the ground that they were exclusive levies on the assessee by the State Government. The assessee contended that such levies were not exclusive levies falling within the scope of Section 40(a)(iib) and therefore, the AO was not justified in disallowing the deductions made on such heads. On appeal, the FAA granted a conditional stay for entertaining the grounds of assessee.

High Court held that,

++ the question that arises for consideration is whether the FAA is justified in imposing condition while granting the stay sought by the assessee. It was contended by assessee that they have the monopoly in the wholesale business of Indian Made Foreign Liquor and beer in the State and they are carrying on the said business on the strength of license issued by the competent authority under the Foreign Liquor Rules. The deduction of Rs.5,75,000/- claimed by assessee which was disallowed, is the licence fee levied exclusively on the assessee by the State Government for the licence issued to them in respect of 23 warehouses. Rule 15A of the Foreign Liquor Rules provides that Gallonage fee at such a rate as the Government may prescribe from time to time shall be paid by the FL-9 licensee on the quantity of Indian made Foreign Liquor sold by such licensee. It is also seen that Gallonage fee of Rs.54,83,87,000/- deducted by assessee which was disallowed, is the fee levied on the assessee exclusively by the State Government under Rule 15A on the quantity of Indian made Foreign Liquor sold by assessee on the strength of the FL-9 licence exclusively granted to them. In so far as FL-9 license is issued in the State under the Foreign Liquor Rules, only to the assessee, in view of the monopoly created in their favour by the State Government, it cannot be contended that the said levies are not exclusive levies on the assessee by the State Government;

++ coming to the remaining deductions which are disallowed, the specific case of the assessee is that the same are levies applicable to others as well. For instance, as far as the shop rental is concerned, it is the case of assessee that retail sale of foreign liquour in the State is not being carried on exclusively by the assessee, but also by the Kerala State Co-operative Consumer Federation Limited also. A reading of Section 40(a)(iib) indicates that exclusivity in terms of the said provision is not to be determined with reference to the issue as to whether anybody else is also being levied the same fee or charge, but it has to be determined having regard to the object of the provision. Looking at the facts in the said perspective, there is no doubt that two views are possible in the matter and the appellate authority cannot therefore be found fault with for having imposed the impugned condition.

(See 2018-TIOL-1108-HC-KERALA-IT)


POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

TIOL Tube Latest

GST Re-Tyred | Episode 2 | Simply inTAXicating

What's New

CGST Rule Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
IGST Rate Notification
UTGST Rate Notification
Cess Rate Notification
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
CBDT Order - IT Return  
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
Excise - Instruction  
Service Tax Circular
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

wso shell wso shell Indoxploit Shell wso shell hacklink hacklink satışı hacklink deface mirror hacklink satış wso shell