News Update

GST on inter establishment supplies - A critique on the Columbia Asia Ruling!GST Council to meet on Sept 28 through video conferencing; Kerala Cess issue to dominate deliberations along with EPCG-related issuesRupee under Hammer! - India needs to brace up for more hardships!Supply of sheep/goat meat - Number of carcasses is of no importance to the Army as their contract is based on weight – supply does not qualify as product put up in ‘Unit container’: AAARGST applicable on liquidated damages under HSN 9997 as ‘Other services’ @18%: AAARConstruction of Solar Power Generating System – supply of said turnkey EPC falls within the definition of ‘Composite supply’ and is a ‘Works Contract’: AAARSetting up and operation of Solar Photovoltaic plant is Works Contract, taxable @18% GST: AAARSupplying food and beverages on the premises of industrial unit/office liable to GST @5% w.e.f 27.07.2018: AARService by commission agents to the agriculturists of turmeric is taxed to ‘Nil’ rate of GST: AARCattle feed in cake form is classifiable under CH 2309 9010 and is exempted: AAR'Disc Brake Pads' is classifiable under heading 8708 3000 as part of motor vehicle – to attract @28% GST: AARI-T - Purpose of scheme under which subsidy is given decides its true nature and sales tax subsidy for setting up new manufacturing unit is capital receipt: ITATRule 96(10) of CGST Rules- Devil lies in the AmendmentsFrom British Raj to Swaraj, Garbage Woes Inundate IndiaCX - Expression used in s.35 is 'presenting' as against 'entertain' in s.35F - as long as appeal is lodged within prescribed period of limitation, it cannot be dismissed on ground that mandatory pre-deposit was not made before expiry of limitation period: HCGST - DGGI nabs two businessmen in Rs 79 Cr tax caseSmall Savings Schemes - Govt notifies interest rates effective from Oct 1Disease Management - Govt ropes in Tata Trust & DellISRO to set up Emergency Response Control Room in MHA63 graded universities are 'cream of the cream', says JavadekarTourist inflow from USA never declined since 2010: GovtGST - ITC abuse - DGGI Gurgaon Unit books two companies for Rs 79 Crore tax evasionUSD 115 mn patent ruling against Samsung set aside by New York CourtSmall Savings Schemes - Govt notifies interest rates for various schemesACC appoints A Gitesh Sarma as Secretary (West) in MEAMaryland mass shooting at Rite Aid Distribution Centre - three killedPrabhu favours dedicated SEZ for Russian companiesED gets 3 months more to wrap up investigation in Aircel-Maxis scamACC grants nod for appointment of four GMs in Railways - P C Sharma for Metro Rail + P S Mishra for South Eastern + Ajay Vijayvergiya for West Central & Rajeev Chaudhry for North CentralCBIC notifies exchange rates for exports & imports purposesIndian economy to surpass USD 5 trillion mark by 2022: PMGovt decides to curb import of non-essential goods to reduce Current Account Deficit
Advance Ruling - A Legal weapon against the Supplier?


JUNE 29, 2018

By Akhil Varghese

IN this article, we shall analyse the ruling pronounced by the Karnataka Advance Ruling Authority in respect of the application filed by M/s Tathagat Health Care Centre LLP.- 2018-TIOL-35-AAR-GST.

Brief facts in the ruling reveal that the applicant is a cardiology specialised hospital providing cardiology related, lifesaving, health care services to the patients. The applicant has taken premises of one floor on rental basis from the existing building of Mallige Hospital for carrying out health care services. The applicant has sought advance ruling on the issue "whether GST is leviable on the rent payable by it?" – while determining the Advance Ruling Authority pronounced that the said service is covered under 'rental or leasing services involving own or leased non-residential property' and is taxable under GST.

We shall now analyse the following questions, in light of the decision pronounced in the aforementioned advance ruling.

-  Whether the ruling given by Authority is in consonance with the GST Law and

-  Whether the authority was right in entertaining the application?

Whether the ruling given is in consonance with GST Law?

Section 7 of the CGST Act inter alia provides that supply includes all forms of supply of goods or services or both such as sale, transfer, barter, exchange , license, rental, lease or disposal made or agreed to be made for a consideration by a person in the course or furtherance of business. From the above definition, it can be concluded that activities such as rental, leasing, etc. made for a consideration in the course or furtherance of business shall qualify as a supply for the purpose of GST.

Notification No. 12/2017 – Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017 provides a list of services which shall be exempt from levy of GST. Among others, it provides that health care services shall be considered as exempt supply. The term "Health Care Services" has been defined under the said notification to mean any service by way of diagnosis or treatment or care for illness, injury, deformity, abnormality or pregnancy in any recognised system of medicines in India and includes services by way of transportation of the patient to and from a clinical establishment .

In the present case, the applicant is the recipient of services. The actual supplier being Mallige Hospital, primarily engaged in healthcare services under GST Law. The premises taken on lease by the applicant is used for providing healthcare services. However, it needs to be noted that the services provided by Mallige Hospital to the applicant would not come within the ambit of definition of health care services. Thus, in view of the author, the said service is squarely covered under GST Law under Entry 5(a) of Schedule II of the CGST Act, wherein it provides that renting of immovable property shall be treated as supply of service and it is a taxable supply under GST Law.

Therefore, the Advance Ruling Authority after analysis of the above aspects has arrived at the decision that the said service is leviable to GST, which is in consonance with the GST Law.

Whether the Advance Ruling Authority is right in entertaining the application?

The second and the most important aspect to be analysed in the light of this ruling is whether the authority was right in passing a ruling on the said application.

Chapter XVII of the CGST Act, 2017 deals with the provision of 'Advance Ruling'. Section 94(a) of the CGST Act defines 'advance ruling' which means a decision provided by the Authority or the Appellate Authority to an applicant on matters or on questions specified in Section 97(2) or Section 100(1), in relation to the supply of goods or services or both being undertaken or proposed to be undertaken by the applicant.

From the definition of advance ruling, it is clear that advance ruling should be in relation to the supply undertaken or proposed to be undertaken by the applicant. However, in the instant case, the applicant is not undertaking any supply in the form of renting of immovable property rather the applicant is receiving the said services. Therefore, the Advance Ruling Authority should not have entertained this application.

Admitting the application in respect of transactions undertaken by any person other than the supplier will create problems since the same can be used as a legal weapon by the department against the activities provided by the supplier.

In future, if the Advance Ruling Authority rightfully rejects an application filed by the recipient of supply citing lack of locus standi, then the fate of this advance ruling may have to be re-determined.

(The author is Associate, Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan, Bangalore and t he views expressed are strictly personal.)

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)


TIOL Tube Latest

Legal Wrangle | International Taxation | Episode 81

What's New

CGST Rule Notification
CGST Rate Notification
CGST Circular
IGST Rate Notification
UTGST Rate Notification
Cess Rate Notification
Income Tax Notification
Income Tax Circular
Customs Tariff Notification
Customs NT Notification
Customs Circular
Anti Dumping Notification
Service Tax Circular
DGFT Notification
DGFT Public Notice
DGFT Circular
RBI Circular

wso shell wso shell Indoxploit Shell wso shell hacklink hacklink satışı hacklink deface mirror hacklink satış wso shell