News Update

Globalisation not yet dead, courtesy ally-shoring, near-shoring & re-shoring!Cloud burst - flash floods - 80 including 22 army personnel missing in SikkimI-T- Prohibition of Benami Property Transaction Act - High Court need not interfere with order sanctioning prosecution of accused person, where proceedings are at premature stage & where subsequent facts and clarifications will emerge only after prosecution is commenced: HCSoccer’s 2030 World Cup to be held in 3 countries - Spain, Portugal & Morocco + Saudi eyeing 2034 World CupI-T- Assessment order passed 3 days after issuing Show Cause Notice - Principles of natural justice contravened as Assessee barely given any time to furnish reply to notice: HCI-T- Revisionary order nowhere mentions how original assessment order is erroneous or prejudicial to revenue's interests; power of revision need not be exercised: HC40 lakhs Americans jabbed updated Covid vaccine in Sept monthI-T- Revenue must proceed on the basis that Assessee need not pay any tax, where appeal is settled in Assessee's favor - any tax paid by Assessee despite not being required to do so, is refundable - Revenue's refusal to refund such tax paid leads to unjust enrichment & is invalid in law: HCCus - Courier Imports and Exports (Electronic Declaration and Processing) Regulations, 2010 - Appellant-Courier deliberately submitted incorrect information to Department in respect of consignments imported by the Appellant - Violation of the Regulations also entail breach of trust by the Appellant - Revocation of couriers' license is upheld: CESTATQuake of 6.3 magnitude scares PhilippinesI-T- Section 153C is only an enabling provision to issue notice notwithstanding anything contained in Sections 139, 147, 148 of I-T Act; Section 153C does not preclude Department from issuing notice for re-assessment u/s 148A to complete assessment u/s 147: HCCX - Since Appellate authority has not considered the contentions of Appellants and passed non-speaking Order, Adjudicating Authority is directed to consider all the issues and after hearing the appellant to pass a reasoned order: CESTATUK fears Russia may mine black sea - Huge risk for civilian shippingI-T- Deduction u/s 80P cannot be denied solely because ITR was filed belatedly, for reasons beyond control of Assessee, more so where mandate of filing ITR within due date didnt exist in relevant AY: ITATST - Since there is no obligation on part of media/media house to give any incentive, receipt of commission/volume discount are voluntary and gratuitous in nature, interference by Tribunal in impugned order absolving liability of assessee from payment of Service Tax is uncalled for: CESTATNobel Prize for chemistry goes to three scientists for development of quantum dotsI-T - If AO has not specified charges for which he wishes to visit assessee with penalty, then penalty order is not sustainable: ITATI-T - If payee/recipient had reflected certain income in his return, he cannot be held to be in default so as to call for any disallowance u/s 40(a)(ia): ITATCabinet okays Terms of Reference for Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal - IILuaDream - CERT-In issues alert against new malware targeting telecom sectorCabinet nod to promulgation of Tenancy Regulations for 3 Union TerritoriesYet another shooting incident in Baltimore, USA; 5 persons injuredNIIF, Japanese Bank for International Cooperation to collaborate on strategies to cut carbon emissionsDress and Address in CourtsOECD brokers multilateral convention to implement Global Minimum Tax subject to tax rule
Upgrade and Stabilize Insolvency and Banking Code

AUGUST 13, 2021

By TIOL Edit Team

WHEN a long-gestated reform becomes a perennial work-in-progress (WIP), it is time to call spade a spade. The list of WIP reforms is lengthening with Goods and Services tax (GST) being its show-piece. Rivalling GST is Insolvency and Banking Code (IBC) in terms of its impact on the economy.

A prolonged WIP creates uncertainty in the economy. It acts as a speed-breaker against revenue-generating capital investments by the private sector. A WIP thus acts as drag on entrepreneurship, economic growth and jobs creation.

Frequent amendments to a legislation underlying a major reform reflects poor drafting. It shows reluctance to incorporate ideas thrown up during the consultation process - both at pre-legislation and post draft bill for discussion stages.

Enacted in 2016, IBC has already been amended six times and requires a few more amendments. A major amendment required is to create a statutory framework for cross-border resolution of insolvency of companies that operate in more than one country.

IBC's implementation is pathetic. Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance (PSC) has done a commendable job by turning torchlight on IBC's "Pitfalls and Solutions".

In its 32nd report presented to Parliament this week, PSC has recommended: "the design and the implementation of the Code as it has evolved needs to be revisited, particularly in the light of its original aims and objects". It continued: "We therefore need a thorough evaluation of the extent of fulfilment of these aims and objects in the course of implementation of the Code over the years".

If one judges off-hand the outcome of IBC since its enforcement in May 2016 against objects and reasons stated in IBC Bill, 2015, the rating would be negative.

The Bill had claimed that its enactment would pave the way for resolution of insolvency in "time bound manner for maximization of value of assets" of loan defaulting entities. The Code would" promote entrepreneurship, availability of credit and balance the interests of all the stakeholders including alteration in the priority of payment of government dues ".

The Bill added: "An effective legal framework for timely resolution of insolvency and bankruptcy would support development of credit markets and encourage entrepreneurship".

As put by PSC, "the low (debt) recovery rates with haircuts as much as 95% and the delay in resolution process with more than 71% cases pending for more than 180 days clearly point towards a deviation from the original objectives of the Code". It has rightly called putting a "benchmark for the quantum" of haircut (loan sacrifices by lenders) comparable to global standards.

PSC deserves plaudits for seeking crucial reforms in the working of committee of creditors (CoC), Insolvency Professionals (IPs) and National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).

The Government's contention that "the commercial wisdom of CoC is supreme" is strange and it thus has an overwhelming role in deciding fate of companies under the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP). If their collective wisdom was supreme, would the banks & financial institutions have doled out loans to companies without adequate due diligence and foresight?

No wonder then to find PSC seeing an "urgent need to have a professional code of conduct for the CoC which will define and circumscribe their decisions, as these have larger implications for the efficacy of the code".

PSC has voiced apprehension about the competence of young IPs, without any experience, in handling the affairs of huge and complex corporations. As put by the Committee, "there are numerous conduct issues" with regards to IPs. Two regulators have taken disciplinary action against 123 IPs.

According to PSC, the main reason for time over-run in insolvency resolution process are the delays in approval of resolution plans by the NCLT. It found 71% of 13170 cases pending with NCLT for more than 180 days. The debt involved in these cases if Rs 9,00,000 crore.

NCLT takes considerable time to admit cases. During this time, a loan defaulting company remains in the control of the promoter. This enables owners to resort to value shifting, funds diversion and asset transfers.

PSC has recommended that NCLT should accept defaulters within 30 days and transfer control of their companies to resolution process within this timeframe.

The Government apathy in filling up vacancies has transformed NCLT into a lame-duck institution. As noted by PSC, "the committee is deeply concerned to note that more than 50% of the sanctioned strength of NCLT is lying vacant and that "the issue of vacancy has plagued the tribunals for years".

Adding to unfilled vacant posts of staff in NCLT, as many as 278 posts of officers and other employees were vacant in NCLT benches, according to reply to Rajya Sabha question dated 9th March 2021.

PSC report contains other valuable recommendations too. A lot has been written and reported by experts on reforming IBC. We hope the Government would collate all valuable suggestions into a consultation paper on final amendments to IBC.

We would urge the Government to consider the need to provide for special resolution of companies that fall sick or turn loan defaulters due to policy flip-flops or judiciary striking down a policy such as 2G licencing and coal blocks allotment.

The PIL-induced Court interventions often lead to suspension of project work or temporary closure of factories. These, in turn, have profound impact on viability of the businesses.

In such cases, promoters just can't be blamed and deprived of management control of their dream projects. The national lockdown prior to emergence of first wave and due to state-wide lockdowns during the second wave are having profound impact on companies especially in the services sector. Lockdown was a policy decision and its IBC brunt should be borne jointly by the Centre and the States. Crackdown on wilful loan defaulters should not create collateral damage of enhancing aversion to take loans. The non-performing assets (NPAs) in financial services sector won't come down as long as there is laxity in the working of banks.

Lending frauds in banking sector are facilitated by unwarranted banking secrecy. This has a direct bearing on IBC. We hope Government would take a multi-dimensional view of loan defaults to reboot IBC.


TIOL Tube Latest

A Tete-a-tete with Larry Summers

TIOL Tube brings you an interview with former US Secretary of Treasury, Mr. Larry Summers who was recently in Delhi.

Mr. Vishweshwar Mudigonda, Partner, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India LLP sharing his thoughts at the TIOL Awards 2022 event.