News Update

GST - Neither SCN nor the order spell out the reasons for retrospective cancellation of registration, hence cannot be sustained: HCGST - Non-application of mind - If reply was unsatisfactory, details could have been sought - Record does not reflect that such exercise was done - Matter remitted: HCGST - Merely because a taxpayer has not filed returns for some period does not mean that registration is required to be cancelled with retrospective date also covering the period when returns were filed and taxpayer was compliant: HCGST - Petitioner's reply, although terse, is not taken into account while passing assessment orders - Petitioner put on terms, another opportunity provided: HCUnveil One Nation; One Debt Code; One Compliance Rule for Centre & StatesChina moves WTO against US tax subsidies for EVs & renewable energyMore on non-doms - The UK Spring Budget 2024 (See TII Edit)Notorious history-sheeter Mukhtar Ansari succumbs to cardiac arrest in UP jailTraining Program for Cambodian civil servants commences at MussoorieNY imposes USD 15 congestion taxCBIC revises tariff value of edible oils, gold & silver45 killed as bus races into ravine in South AfricaCBIC directs all Customs offices to remain open on Saturday & SundayBankman-Fried jailed for 25 yrs in FTX scamI-T- Once the citizen deposits the tax upon coming to know of his liability, it cannot be said that he has deliberately or willfully evaded the depositing of tax and interest in terms of Section 234A can be waived: HCHouthis attack continues in Red Sea; US military shoots down 4 dronesI-T- Secured creditor has priority charge over secured asset, over claims of I-T Department & other Departments; any excess amount recovered by Secured Creditor from auction of secured asset, over & above the dues payable to it, are to be remitted to the Departments: HCFederal Govt hands out USD 60 mn to rebuild collapsed bridge in BaltimoreI-T - Receipts of sale of scrap being part & parcel of activity and being proximate thereto would also be within ambit of gains derived from industrial undertaking for purpose of computing deduction u/s 80-IB: HCCanadian School Boards sue social media titans for 4 bn Canadian dollar in damagesI-T - Once assssee on year of reversal has paid taxes on excess provision and similar feature appeared in earlier years and assesee had payments for liquidated damages on delay of deliverables, no adverse inference can be drawn: HCFormer IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt jailed for 20 yrs for planting drugs to frame lawyerST - Software development service & IT-enabled service provided by assessee was exempt from tax during relevant period, by virtue of CBEC's Notification & Circular; demands raised for such period not sustainable: CESTATUN says Households waste across world is now at least one billion meals a dayCus - Order rejecting exporter's request for conversion of Shipping Bills on grounds that the same has been made by exporter beyond period of three months from date of Let Export Order in terms of CBEC Circular No. 36/2010-Cus : CESTATIndia, China hold fresh dialogue for complete disengagement on Western borders: MEACus - No Cess is payable when Basic Customs Duty is found to be Nil: CESTATThakur says India is prepared for 2036 OlympicsCX - As per settled law, a right acquired as result of a statutory provision, cannot be taken away retrospectively unless said statutory provision so provides or by necessary implication has such effect: CESTAT
 
GST - Age is just a number

JULY 01, 2022

By Vinod Yadav

A new era in the field of Indian indirect taxation system was heralded 5 years ago when Goods and Service Tax (GST), the much touted and the most significant structure of indirect taxation ever - was introduced.

As usual, in some quarters, the timing of launch was questioned while pessimists had premonitions of its utter failure. Gloom mongers emphatically foretold about its doom within a year. But many of them went ahead and compared this unpredictable change in taxation system as Gabbar Singh Tax, coined after the negative and dreaded character, depicted in the 70s Bollywood blockbuster Sholay, who was pitted against the protagonist – Thakur.

To mollify the angst in the minds of ordinary taxpayers, GST was promised as a Good and Simple Tax system with the buzzword 'Ease of doing business'.

However, once the GST juggernaut started rolling on, driven largely on the electronics wheels, it emanated many signals to taxpayers to speculate on its efficacy to them. 'Ease of Business' seemed a misnomer while the actual intent appeared to be Ease of Business for the tax administration!

During the last 5 years of its existence, GST has succeeded to differentiate itself from Gabbar at least on the implementation of -

a. Automated mechanism of indirect taxation which was a far cry a few years back which had lead to widespread evasion of taxation;

b. Never conceived before system of E Invoice to curb fake invoicing issues;

c. Electronic Way Bill system tracking efficiently the movement of goods - end to end.

Pertinent to mention that Malaysia also took a plunge into this venture with India, but failed to emerge from the initial setback in its implementation and eventually withdrew from it, although Malaysia is not as gigantic in area and population and complex demographically as India. In fact, India serves as a role model for the entire world, especially the struggling economies where tax administration is in doldrums.

There is not an iota of Gabbar in the accomplishments.

However, Gabbar appears to have sneaked in from the back door in the garb of given infirmities:

1. Technical glitches every now and then cuts a sorry figure for the ease of business slogan;

2. Too many and too often changes in GST provisions and procedures is indeed punishing for the not so organized entities while it is equally cumbersome for the organized and large set up corporations as well;

3. Seamless flow of ITC suffered jolts when system hitches put a break on it and absurd provisions made it difficult to sail through;

4. The Good and Simple Tax catchphrase is rendered further eclipsed by rampant issue of notices by the department from the multiple GST provisions irrespective of its applicability, leading to avoidable wastage of time and energy. Unless accountability is suitably assigned to the issue of notices, the onslaught is expected to surge further;

5. Given the above and experience with the biased decisions of the quasi-judicial authorities coupled with non-existence of Tribunal makes imminent disputes referred to the higher fora of judiciary which may lead to chaos and protracted litigations.;

6. Conflicting and confusing Advance Rulings continue to create havoc by compounding simple matters in the name of solutions;

7. Enroute confiscation of goods and issue of notices on flimsy grounds without any consideration for practical difficulties and absolutely no inclination to understand the situation or have the demeanor for resolution of issues;

8. The novel concept of the GST Council is yet to make its presence felt positively in some of the vital issues of GST.

To withstand the marauding Gabbar in the Ramgarh (GST ecosystem), the legislative [Thakur] has to focus and optimally utilize Jai & Veeru [overall simplification & redressal mechanism in areas of concern]:

a. More user-friendly compliance system

b. Seamless tax credits throughout the value chain without cascading effects.

c. Simple tax rate

d. One nation, one tax in true spirit. In reality, it is remote in view of issues related to Place of Supply and multiplicity of tax slabs. Now, even States have started deviating from adopting the Central provisions in toto viz. Maharashtra.

e. Petroleum products to be GST net. Largest revenue earner for the Center and the States (more than half of total GST collection) - Petroleum Products are still out of GST makes a mockery of the 'One Nation One Tax' tagline!

f. Making provisions by keeping business needs also in mind, while ensuring a check on evasion.

g. Dispute redressal system has to be in place. Even after 5 years of inception of GST, a Tribunal of GST is still a far cry while a flurry of demands is being issued on a daily basis.

Goodies associated with GST are appealing, but the troubles and tribulations are equally appalling. Based on the status of setting right the shortcomings in Statutes, eradicating technical hiccups and bringing in the direly needed GST Tribunal to set the dispute redressal system robust, it would be concluded if this tax system was really Gabbar Singh Tax or a Good & Simple Tax!

[The author is Lead-GST, Calderys India Refractories Limited, Sadar, Nagpur and the views expressed are strictly personal. The names of the persons/places from the movie Sholay are used purely in jest.]

(DISCLAIMER : The views expressed are strictly of the author and Taxindiaonline.com doesn't necessarily subscribe to the same. Taxindiaonline.com Pvt. Ltd. is not responsible or liable for any loss or damage caused to anyone due to any interpretation, error, omission in the articles being hosted on the site)

POST YOUR COMMENTS
   

AR not Afar by SK Rahman

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri Shailendra Kumar, Trustee, TIOL Trust, giving welcome speech at TIOL Awards 2023




Shri M C Joshi, Former Chairman, CBDT




Address by Shri Buggana Rajendranath, Hon'ble Finance Minister of Andhra Pradesh at TIOL Awards 2023