News Update

FM reviews CAPEX of CPSEsGovt writes to over 2800 corporates to clear MSME duesGovt carrying out reforms in every sector of economy to prop up growth: PMIgnoring limitation proves costlyInverted duty structure - A Case study (See 'TOG Insight' in Taxongo.com)CBIC promotes four officers as Pr Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise + posts Sameer Pandey as DS in GST Council SecretariatSC cannot be a place for Govts to walk in when they choose, ignoring period of limitation prescribed - Petition dismissed as time barred; costs imposed on State for wasting judicial time - amount to be recovered from officers responsible: SCIs penalty compulsorily attracted on late payment of GST?No mutation of COVID-19 detected in India: Health MinisterCus - Goods re-imported for repair and re-exported - Merely because Assessee could claim duty drawback later on and it may give rise to a revenue neutral situation, it cannot be said that period of one year prescribed in 158/95-Cus is without any meaning: HCST - Payment of mobilization advance is a separate financial transaction within contract for providing of service & so is not to be included in gross taxable value as per Section 67 of Finance Act 1994 - duty demand cannot be raised thereon when there is no allegation of any part of contracted value having evaded taxation: CESTATBSVI introduction a revolutionary step: JavadekarCX - It is settled position in law that an assessee is entitled to interest on delayed disbursal of refund after three months from date of filing of refund claim till date of its realisation: CESTATCus - Drawback - After turning down request for taking test samples, Revenue cannot brush aside report given by an expert Committee simply for the reason that sample was not drawn and referred by Department: CESTATPayment made to a trust formed for the benefit of employees of the company, of which the assessee was a shareholder & whose shares the assessee had sold, does not qualify as expenditure incurred wholly in connection with transfer of asset: HCBogus purchases - only the profit element embedded therein is to be disallowed, rather than the entire quantum of purchases made: ITATSearch assessment is invalid where it is completed even before search operations are conducted or where any material incriminating the assessee has not yet been found: ITATWhere assessee did not claim exemption in respect of one residential property, the assessee can avail such benefit in respect of a second house or plot of land: ITATIndia successfully test-fires cruise missile from Indian Navy’s destroyer INS ChennaiCOVID-19: Global tally goes past FOUR Crore with 11.15 lakh deaths; America has close to 27 lakh active cases against 8 lakh in IndiaCOVID-19 - Almost 80% new cases coming from 10 StatesCountrywide S&T infrastructure facilities to be accessible to industry & startups: GovtPM calls for speedy access to vaccines once readyNew Zealand PM earns second term for managing COVID-19 wellDigital Media - Govt to extend all benefits available to othersGovt not considering any DA for Govt employees: GangwarCBDT issues transfer order of 395 Addl / JCITs on All India basisSBI given nod for sale of electoral bonds for 10 daysEducation CESS - the spoilt fruit
 
Englishman's gift to a poor Indian gets stuck in Customs; Mr FM, Pl do something!

By TIOL News Service

NEW DELHI, JAN 19 : Francesca Poelman, a philanthropic Englishman wanted to give a surprise Christmas gift to a poor Indian, Repalemba Jamir who lives in Shillong. Jamirís father is dead and his mother ekes out a living by selling candles. He could have never dreamed of buying a guitar. The poor Englishman not knowing the ways of Indian Customs, decided to bring a little cheer to poor Jamirís life. He bought a second hand guitar and sent it across through a church in Shillong as a very big surprise Christmas gift for Jamir. But Kolkotta Customs does not understand such sentiments. They want Jamir to pay Rs. 40,000/- for the guitar.

Fran Poelman writes to TIOL that neither Jamir, nor the Church through which the guitar was gifted can afford such a huge amount for the guitar. Is Poelman rich? No, He is only good! He tells us that even he canít afford to pay this amount. He bought a second hand guitar as a gift for an unfortunate Indian. But our Customs doesnít work on sentiments; they do on stiff rules. Now Poelman does not know what to do. He, the Church and  Jamir cannot afford to pay the 40,000 demanded by Kolkotta Customs. So the only option is to send the guitar back.

The Customs have a system called facility under which if you are big enough, or know the big people, you can walk past the Customs in our Airports with a little more than the allowed free baggage and may be a couple of more scotch bottles than permitted. Who are these people who avail the Customs facility? ­ of evading a small amount of Customs duty? The rich and powerful of the society, who only get thrilled by getting the customs facility. A Sachin Tendulkar can get a Ferrari imported free of duty, but a guitar gifted by a poor Englishman to a poor Indian! No chance! We follow the law strictly. 

Please could you help me? pleads Mr Fran Poelman (See full text of his letter as given below).

TIOL appeals to the Finance Minister, the Chairman, CBEC and the Chief Commissioner, Kolkotta Customs to help. Please hand over that guitar to Repalemba Jamir. Much more than customs duty is involved here.

51 Melbourne Avenue
Chelmsford
Essex. CM1 2DP
England
Fax number Ė 01245 318701
 
To whom it may concern,

Please, could you help me?

At the beginning of December 2004 I sent a guitar as a gift to a friend, Repalemba Jamir. He lives in a town called Shillong in Meghalaya. I had bought the guitar in February last year. In December I wanted to send it to my friend in India as his father has died and he has absolutely no way of being able to buy a guitar for himself now that his mother has very little money to spend. The small amount she does make selling candles just helps them to make ends meet. I decided that I wanted to bless Repalemba and send him the guitar I had bought in February as a very big surprise for Christmas. When I spoke to the company here in England, Ocean International, based in Southampton, they assured me that there would be no problem in sending the guitar and that as I was sending as a gift to Repalemba through his church in Shillong then the customs tax needed to be paid should not be too much.

However, the guitar is still at the Federal Express depot in Calcutta and the customs official has reported to Repalemba that they will not deliver the guitar until he pays Rs 40000/-. This works out to be approximately £550. This is terrible as the guitar and the accessories I sent with it are valued at no more than £600 now that is second hand.

I have spoken to some of the Indian traders I know here in Essex and they informed me that a mistake must have been made because this amount is much too much.
 
I would be grateful if you could let me know if the amount that the customs officials are asking for in Calcutta is correct. My friend cannot pay this money, neither can the church we are sending it to and neither can I as it cost me quite a lot of money to send it in the first place. Please could you assist me in this matter? I would be grateful if you could deal with my request in writing, either by fax or letter, so that I can forward any information you give me to Repalemba. I fear that if this is the correct amount then we will have to ask Federal Express to return the guitar back to England.
 
Yours faithfully,

Francesca Poelman
franpoelman@hotmail.com


 RECENT DISCUSSION(S) POST YOUR COMMENTS
   
 
Sub: Englishman's gift

Suggest that FM/CBEC should formulate a rules & regulation so that the GENIUNE persons are benefited by the loved gift given by others

Posted by MURALIKRISHNAMURTHY MURALIKRISHNAMURTHY