News Update

White House expected to up tariffs on several Chinese goods in coming weekJaishankar to take up Kartarpur entry fee of USD 20 with PakistanWHO reports some progress on pandemic treaty but deadline is missedKCR says regional parties can form Govt at Delhi with outside support from NDA or INDIASevere solar storm envelopes earth; may disrupt power grids and communicationsTrump’s youngest son Barron backs out of Republican Party’s July conventionIndia to participate at 77th Cannes Film FestivalIndustrial production tapers down to 4.9% in March monthDoT, MHA and State Police join hands to combat cyber fraudstersSC grants interim bail to Kejriwal only for poll-related activitiesICG signs MoU for supply of indigenous marine-grade aluminum for construction of shipsDeath toll in TN cracker unit blast rises to 10BJD promises to make Odisha No 1 State by 2036; Manifesto promises AI UnivGST - Even assuming that dues to sundry creditors were not discharged, only the trade payables and not receivables should have been taken into account: HCGoogle search engine waits to meet rival from OpenAI on MondayGunman shoots two officers in Paris Police StationGST - Neither the Show Cause Notice nor the order spell out the reasons for retrospective cancellation, hence same cannot be sustained: HCUS rebuffs Russian allegation of meddling in Indian electionsChina upgrades ties with Hungary to ‘all-weather’ partnershipGST - SC asks Govt not to use coercion for recovering arrearsPrivate equity funds pouring in India’s healthcare sector

MESSAGE BOARD

   

North Block watches as GSTN plays havoc with PM's historic tax reform!


A GOOD SYSTEM BADLY IMPLEMENTED

Thanks for your timely article on failure of GSTN System. The current havac and revenue leakage are result of poor implementation system. Some of the exampes are as under:-
Matching system was the crux of the GSt returns. Non payment of GST and issuance of Invoices years is the basic failure system. The field staff of GST is not in position to analyse data even available in portal due to lack of infrastructure. If R-1 and related credit matching has been enabled earlier no such instances held.
2. Recently automated refund system introduced, that is good step but the problem is incompetency in the part of field formation who reject refund claim even all the documents uploaded in portal by applicants, and poor applicant again file the same.
3. How the Officers analyse the data of assesses, which do not contain details of quantity in R-1, how price comparison can be done and correct valuation be ascertained due to lack of complete data in GST Portal. The HSN summary contain quantity which can not be a basis of analysis of Invoices.
Above are some of the example and list is long. The poor implementation of the system is the root cause of failure of GSTN, although it has many defects.
The poor assesses suffer from all this and this one increased the trust deficit and no one is willing to do anything new due to this poor stage of GST implementation.
As suggested by you, the PM should himself resolve the matter.

SATYA PRAKASH SINGH 18/02/2020

 

Back

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri N K Singh, recipient of TIOL FISCAL HERITAGE AWARD 2023, delivering his acceptance speech at Fiscal Awards event held on April 6, 2024 at Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi.


Shri Ram Nath Kovind, Hon'ble 14th President of India, addressing the gathering at TIOL Special Awards event.