News Update

TIOL wishes all Netizens a very Happy Dussehra!French cognac braces up for Chinese tariffChina probes Foxconn staffers for briberyUS imposes fresh sanctions against Iran for attack on Israel + EU to impose sanctions for transfer of Iranian missile to RussiaBoeing to trim 17K jobs amid on-going strikeNo let up in Trump’s rhetoric against migrants81st Network Planning Group evaluates 5 infra projectsNobel Peace Prize goes to Japanese NGO Nihon Hidankyo which works with atomic bomb survivors in Hiroshima & NagasakiCongress extends support to NC for forming government in J&KWHO accredits CDSCO, NRAI for functional vaccine regulatory systemAs over 560 Kgs of Cocaine seized in Delhi & Mumbai, ED conducts Search operations against kingpinsLate industrialist and renowned philanthropist Ratan Tata’s brother Noel Tata succeeds him as Chairman of Tata TrustsGST - Impugned order was passed in violation of principles of natural justice since it is just and necessary to provide an opportunity to the petitioner to establish their case on merits - Matter remanded subject to petitioner paying 15% of disputed tax: HCR G Kar rape-murder case - protesting junior doctors’ hunger strike enters 6th day; one criticalMusk promises to make robotaxi available by 2027GST - Since only a SCN has been issued, it is premature for the petitioner to challenge the same by approaching Court: HCMishap in Colorado gold mine - 1 dead, 12 trappedUkraine goes for biggest tax hike to fund warADB raises economic growth projections for developing Asia and the PacificCBIC issues posting-cum-transfer order of 7 PCC & CCs

MESSAGE BOARD

   

GST on TDR


tdr

sir no where in the statute the word development rights or transferable development rights words or phrases are used sir.
these are generated by common people or consultants and then picked up by the council and used in notifications and circulars, which has become a bureaucratic practice now a days.

when development on land is development only then its rights are also land na sir. then schedule 3 item only.
builder gets the permission only to enter and construct the project , nothing can be transferred for that by the land owner neither the land nor the rights thereon . referring to certain hsn code can not bring the taxability. article is nice and started as well too, but sir at end it has spoken the language of the revenue.

decisions in the ananda behre, chheda housing, sadoday builders etc are very relevant till today hold good.

no taxability as there is no supply it self

Navin Khandelwal 07/08/2023

 

Back

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri Samrat Choudhary, Hon’ble Deputy CM & FM of State of Bihar, delivering inaugural speech at TIOL Tax Congress 2024.



Justice A K Patnaik, Mentor to Hon'ble Jury for TIOL Awards 2024, addressing the gathering at the event.