News Update

GST - Assistant Commissioner discarded reply filed by a one-liner observation that explanation given is not comprehensible, conceivable, not perspicuous and is ambiguous - SCN cannot be decided in such cavalier manner: HCKerala GST - Tax treatment of discounts received by petitioner from its suppliers - case remanded as this aspect was overlooked while passing assessment orders: HCGST - Petitioner's refund application stalled due to it being listed as risky exporter; Proper Officer directed to dispose off refund application in 2 months' time; petitioner at liberty to seek removal from risky exporter list: HCKejriwal offers free treatment for all senior citizens at all Delhi hospitalsCX - Rule 10 of Pan Masala Packing Machines (Capacity Determination and Collection of Duty) Rules - condition of a continuous period exceeding 15 days was met, regardless of how it was spread over multiple months - Abatement be allowed: HCSC backs Madras HC ruling ordering CBI probe into hooch tragedyCus - Once duty liability under EPCG scheme is settled, penalty imposed u/s 112(a) of Customs Act, which is tied to confiscation provisions of Section 111(o), cannot be enforced: HCMalaysia’s Foreign Minister fined for smoking in publicMultiple Adjournments of Appeals, After Issue of Final Order - Attempt to Restore ThemDRI faces Canon - againCENVAT Credit for Telecom Tower Erection: A Boon for IndustryTrump says India collects a lot of tariff; threatens reciprocal taxI-T - Recourse to Rule 8D for computing disallowance u/s 14A is available only if taxpayer's computation of expenses attributable to earning exempt income, is found to be inadequate: HCGoa CM’s wife sues AAP MP Sanjay Singh for Rs 100 CrI-T - Reopening u/s 148 can't be sustained, in case of apparent disconnect between reasons which were originally recorded for initiation of reassessment and disclosures which stand embodied in final assessment order: HCSyrian rebels dig out mass grave - ‘machinery of death’ under AssadI-T - Reopening of assessment is not permitted beyond period as stipulated u/s 149(1): HCTrump all set to roll back Biden’s EV policiesI-T - Order passed by Tribunal premised on incorrect facts regarding service of CIT(A)'s order on assessee's correct address, which was actually incorrect, merits re-adjudication: HCFTC bans hidden junk fees in hotelI-T - Once issue is already scrutinized during regular assessment, then same issue can't be considered for assumption of jurisdiction to reopen assessment, as it would amount to change of opinion: HCNASA again delays home-coming of astronauts stuck at Space StationI-T- Additions framed merit being set aside where assessee sufficiently explains source of bank deposits as coming from own deposits & cash gifts received from close family: ITATCBIC launches new initiatives to enhance taxpayer's servicesI-T- Exemption u/s 54 is allowed based on amount utilized from sale consideration towards construction of a property, even if construction is not completed: ITATIndia's pharma market for FY 2023-24 peaks beyond USD 50 billionCus - As per settled legal position, freight is not included in duty calculation when foreign vessel is imported for first time: CESTATCCPA notices to 45 coaching centers for misleading advertisement: MoSCus - In absence of any condition of end use certificate in Notification, same cannot be imposed and for that reason exemption cannot be denied: CESTATPLI for medical devices allocated Rs 3420 Cr: MoSCus - Duty payable on ship stores consumed during ship's coastal run, is rightly excluded while finalising Bill of Entry: CESTATNew DPSUs will carry forward modernisation & indigenisation: RMCus - CBLR - Regulation 10(e) stands contravened as broker failed to exercise due diligence in handling documents & filing import declarations by permitting unauthorised use of it's dongle for filing bill of entries: CESTATUnion Minister invites Uniqlo to invest in PM's Mega ParksCus - Order revoking Customs broker's license & forfeiting security deposit and imposing penalty, are untenable where timelines prescribed for issuing SCN, submitting inquiry reports & passing order, are not adhered to: CESTAT
 
RACs have lost the RACE! Can Help Centres deliver the goods?

TIOL-DDT 120
24 05 2005
Tuesday

Anti-dumping duty on acrylic fibre

Anti-dumping duty on acrylic fibre from UK, Germany, Bulgaria and Brazil is withdrawn. The anti-dumping duty was provisionally imposed by Notification No. 133/2001-Cus, dated 31.12.2001 which was conformed by Notification No. 104/2002-Cus, dated 9.10.2002. Now this Notification No. 104/2002 is rescinded.

Notification No. 48/2005-Cus., dated 19.05.2005.

Anti-dumping duty on Acrylic Fibre below 1.5 denier

Similarly anti-dumping duty on acrylic fibre below 1.5 denier from Italy was imposed provisionally by Notification No. 4/2002-Cus, dated 10.1.2002 and confirmed by Notification No. 95/2002-Cus, dated 12.9.2002. Now this Notification No. 95/2002 is rescinded thereby withdrawing the anti-dumping duty.

Notification No. 49/2005-Cus., dated 19.05.2005.

RACs have lost the RACE! Can Help Centres deliver the goods?

Recently Board has issued a Circular 815/12/2005 CX dated May 13, 2005 on setting up of Help Centres. The Circular reproduced the following para of the FM’ Budget Speech.

“As a measure of facilitation, I propose to follow international practice and establish large taxpayer units (L.T.Us). To begin with, these units will be set up in major cities. I would like to invite large taxpayers, whether of corporate tax or income tax or excise duties or service tax, to participate in the programme and avail of the single window service. For small taxpayers, I propose to set up Help Centres in cooperation with industry associations, professional bodies and NGOs.”

Accordingly, Board desires that at-least one Help Centre may be set up in each Commissionerate under Additional/ Joint Commissioner.. The prime objective of the Help Centre is to help the honest tax payer/small assessees/ importers and exporters/ service providers by providing an institutional mechanism for guiding and educating them in all matters relating to Customs, Central Excise and Service Tax. The Centre will make them aware of their rights and obligations as also advantages of tax compliance and consequences of non-compliance. The non-filers, stop-filers of Returns and defaulters of monthly payment of duty will also be an area of focus.

The work of the Help Centre should be systematic with prompt assistance to the trade and a proper record should be maintained containing the number of persons approaching the Help Centre, issues raised and the manner in which the help is provided.

We already have an institutional mechanism for guiding the assesses in the name of Regional Advisory Committees with more or less similar objectives. RACs are set up in the Commissionerates for interaction between the Trade and the Department. In this Committee, the Commissioner of Central Excise will be the Ex-Officio Chairman. In order to redress the difficulties faced by the assessees in relation to the procedural/policy matters of the Central Excise laws, the Committee meets periodically and discusses the issues raised by the members of the trade. Because the law enforcing officers are believed to possess better expertise in understanding the law than the ordinary assessee, it is expected that the practical difficulties in following the procedures by the trade will be resolved or at least be forwarded to the higher formations.

But, unfortunately, instead of providing any reasonable solutions, the points are often replied to in evasive manner. And for some of the points raised, the officers themselves have no answers nor have any possible solutions. Even if they can find an answer, it is always better for the officers to play safe by not giving any specific solution, with the result that the RAC meetings turned out to be a routine exercise in futility. In its earlier days the RAC meetings used to be attended by the top executives of the companies but slowly they lost interest as they had come to realise that these meetings do not offer any solutions and at best they are an exercise in PR. So now you find RAC meetings attended by three assessees and thirty officers. The minutes of RAC meetings are full of wry humour.

Look at a few samples -

Point raised by a CHA :

Point No 1 Even though the service was brought under the net from 16th July 1997, there remains a lot of confusion for the exemptions and the exact amount on which the service tax is payable. In case of lump sum billing, the actual reimbursement is excluded and the rest of amount is considered for 15% assessable value and the service tax is applied. Confirm whether the above system is correct.

Reply: Refer Sub Section 29 of Section 65 of Chapter V of the Finance Act, 1994

What a reply! The CHA was referring to a Board Circular wherein it has been decided to charge service tax on 15% of the gross amount in case of lump sum billing and he was asked to refer to the definition of the service under Section 65!

Point No 2: As a Customs House Agent, lot of service is availed from various service providers and service tax is paid by them. Clarify whether all such service tax paid can be taken credit on the total service tax liability.

Reply: Refer Clause (L) of Rule 2 of Cenvat Credit rules.

If you are a regular follower of RAC minutes, you will find several such amusing replies to the difficulties expressed by the trade. Assessees do not attend RAC meetings to be told to read sections of the Act. They can do so far better in the cosy comforts of their offices instead of wasting time in attending these meetings. Only time will tell how the proposed help centres by the FM function as real help centres.

Until Tomorrow with more DDT

Have a Nice Day.

Mail your comments to
vijaywrite@taxindiaonline.com

TIOL Tube Latest

Conferment of TIOL Awards 2024. The event was held on October 1, 2024 at Taj Palace, New Delhi



Technical Session I - Ease of Doing Business: GST on Digital Economy