News Update

Cus - Subsequent to order under challenge, Customs Broker Licence of appellant has been revoked, appeal becomes infructuous: CESTATCus - Since the licence has ultimately been revoked, appeal directed against confirmation of suspension of Customs Broker licence, has been rendered infructuous: CESTATCus - Once verification of address is complete, if client moves to a new premises and does not inform authorities or does not get his documents amended, such act or omission of client cannot be held against Customs Broker: CESTATCus - Once verification of address is complete, if client moves to a new premises and does not inform authorities or does not get his documents amended, such act or omission of client cannot be held against Customs Broker: CESTATCus - Subsequent to order under challenge, Customs Broker Licence of appellant has been revoked, appeal becomes infructuous: CESTATCus - Subsequent to order under challenge, Customs Broker Licence of appellant has been revoked, appeal becomes infructuous: CESTATSuspension & Revocation of Customs Broker LicenseIranian President Ebrahim Raisi, foreign minister die in chopper crash in northwestern IranI-T - Escapement of income due to claim of deduction u/s 80-IB(10) was certainly a subject matter of appeal and admittedly so and on this income reassessment is not permissible : HCPatanjali staffers jailed after much-hyped ‘Soan Papdi’ fails food standardsFSSAI alerts Fruit Traders against use of Calcium Carbide in Fruit RipeningBlowback for Sunak mulling curbs on post-study visas for foreign studentsI-T - Additions framed u/s 68 on account of unexplained cash credit cannot be sustained where AO does not specify how such additions had been computed: ITATIranian President Raisi’s death confirmed in copter crashPoll-related seizures piling up close to Rs 9,000 croresI-T - Charitable organisation cannot be denied registration u/s 12AB solely on grounds that it is managed by one person, but where its activities are for the benefit of the entire society at large: ITATIndonesian volcano turns active; 7 villages evacuatedCitizens join big time with EC to check electoral malpracticesCongo Military claims it foiled serious bid of coup involving Americans and British menI-T - Material to be considered for invoking Search assessment should be seized in course of search u/s 132 of the Act on searched action or requisitioned u/s 132A: ITATNew Taiwanese President assumes office amid rising tensions from China889 candidates to contest elections in Phase 6I-T - Failure of AO in recording the satisfaction based on any material seized during the course of the search, vitiates search assessment proceeding: ITATECI seizures inches close to Rs 9000 Cr; 45% of seizures are drugsPMLA - If accused appears before Special Court pursuant to summons, he shall not be treated as if he is in custody and it is not necessary for him to apply for bail : SC (See 'TIOLCorplaws')Delhi logs 44.4 degrees temperature on SundayCus - Warehoused goods cleared for export & was bound for foreign-going vessel; Customs officers issued Let Export order; Department's allegation of goods being diverted not backed by evidence, hence unsustainable: CESTATAmnesty Scheme for exporters: Govt recovers Rs 852 CroreCustoms - CBIC prescribes undertaking from importers of lubrication oil for clearance of consignmentGas tanker blast in Pune; Hotels, houses guttedST - Dry Leasing - Agreement between assessee & party for leasing jet aircraft with possession solely at risk of lessee along with maintenance, is not Supply of Tangible Goods; transaction amounts to Deemed Sale under Article 366(29A) of Constitution & hence excluded from Service Tax levy: CESTATViolations of economic sanctions: Criminal penalties come into forceST - Commissionerate at Raipur lacks jurisdiction to issue SCN demanding tax for such service which was provided by assessee's unit in Delhi, where service in question is rendered outside jurisdiction of Raipur Commissionerate: CESTATBengaluru Customs nabs 4 pax with gold powder worth Rs 1.96 CroreST - No question of suppression of facts would arise where assessee regularly files returns & maintains proper books; extended limitation need not be invoked in these circumstances: CESTAT
 
Does GST mean 'Go Slow Tax' reform for States in India? - A case for Single GST

TIOL - COB(WEB) - 142
JULY 02, 2009

By Shailendra Kumar, Editor

THE Union Budget 2009 is only three days away. The Finance Minister's speech must be going through the last leg of proof-reading. If we leave aside the Part B which generally focuses on tax proposals, one futuristic statement which the entire nation, or at least the pragmatists in business houses and the academia, appear to be waiting for is going to be relating to the proposed Goods & Services Tax (GST). It has become almost certain that India is going to miss the April 1, 2010 deadline for GST. In this backdrop, it would indeed be interesting to see what roadmap the Finance Minister is going to roll out not only before the domestic industry but also the external sector which seems to be pinning high hope on this proposed reform of indirect taxes in India.

For the Finance Minister, it is going to be a tough challenge to commit the Union Government to a future model and a concrete date. Since the Budget is a solemn announcement on the floor of the House, the Finance Minister would hopefully think twice before making a promise to the nation. However, he should not, at the same time, shy away from committing the UPA Government to the proposed reforms. It is equally important that the Minister does not seek shelter under rhetoric and oratories. It is a historic opportunity to put India in the global league of rising economic dragons like China. China has already achieved a unified VAT system, and it seems to be working well for its economy. There are multiple indicators of the same, and FDI is one of them.

Going by the recommendations of the Empowered Committee of State FMs and the consensus views of the noted experts, a dual system of GST is argued to be better suited to the fiscal federalism provided by the Indian Constitution. The most common line of argument is that since our Constitution provides clear-cut powers to the Central Govt and the States to levy taxes, and the same is translated into reality with the aid of Union List, State List and Concurrent List, the dual system is the only feasible solution to bridge the gap or bring them together at one platform.

One of the arguments is that even if the Constitution is amended to make legal space for a single GST, it would upset the fiscal federalism which is one of the cornerstones of the Indian polity. Another limitation that is often invoked by such experts is that the basic feature of the Constitution cannot be altered.

Going by such arguments it appears that these experts have been digging for solutions first, and then set the 'goal' of a single or dual GST! The most logical approach would be to keep the goal in sight and then endeavour hard to evolve a solution which not only ensures political and federal harmony but is also futuristic and meets the needs of the economy.

Let's take the example of WTO. What WTO has done in the past one decade is to emerge as a super-government at international arena. For all cross-border transactions its fiat runs uncurtailed. The legal framework and policy contours prescribed and agreed upon by its Members have got binding force, and it neutralises the concept of sovereignty of a nation. If a country decides to exercise its right to sovereignty and ignores the deadline for policy changes, fixed by WTO, a country runs the risk of being declared an economic pariah. And no country in today's globalised world can afford to remain isolated even for a week. In this case all directions coming from WTO Secretariat whether it dilutes the currency of sovereignty of a nation or neutralises it completely, has to be followed. In this backdrop of new global multilateral framework of governance, the concept of sovereignty has lost its meaning.

Similarly, the concept of federalism automatically stands diluted if India has to emerge as a unified common market with minimal tax compliance cost to its business entities and prevention of cascading effect of input tax load. If India is aiming at becoming an economic superpower in the next two decades, it has got to adopt a futuristic tax model rather than indulging in short-term compromises with the whims of States ruled by political parties having 'local vision' which is going to be not less than a 'fiscal treason'!

The Union Government should not give up on its demand for a single GST. It should also not look for a parallel in other continents as all those examples where dual system has been introduced pertain to a specific time period in the past, and a time will soon come when those countries will also be moving towards a unified GST regime. Merely because they could not achieve it in the past like Canada, it does not speak of their inability to do so in the future. India need not stop where some of the countries with similar federal structure had to stop because of the limitation of their historic forces if India has to stand out in the crowd of economically-muscled nations.

It undoubtedly makes no sense that the Central Govt will have Central GST comprising of Central Excise and Service Tax, and States will have VAT, many local taxes and also perhaps power to levy tax on local services. This sort of fractured or multiple-levy-approach would once again countervail the efficacy of the new system and would pose teething problems for passing on credit for tax paid on input services. Let's take the example of what the Empowered Committee has to say about availment of input tax credit (ITC): ''Cross utilization of ITC between the Central GST and the State GST should not be allowed.'' If the idea is to minimise the cascading effect of input tax load on output, all efforts must be made to allow credit rather than artificially restrict it.

Let's hope good sense prevails on the UPA Government and also squabbling State Finance Ministers who need to rise above their narrow interests to grab the right to tax and support the general cause for a single GST which alone can be said to be the attainment of the complete indirect tax reform. Let's hear what our Finance Minister has to say and then decide what India is heading for?

TIOL Tube Latest

Shri N K Singh, recipient of TIOL FISCAL HERITAGE AWARD 2023, delivering his acceptance speech at Fiscal Awards event held on April 6, 2024 at Taj Mahal Hotel, New Delhi.


Shri Ram Nath Kovind, Hon'ble 14th President of India, addressing the gathering at TIOL Special Awards event.